Repository navigation
docs(plan): PLAN-CLEAN-5 live status and decisions of 18.10. - #1708
Conversation
No-Test: plan text only Co-Authored-By: GPT-6 <noreply@openai.com>
Cuarroc
added
the
review-ok
Codex Review SummaryThis comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHubYour team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings. |
![chatgpt-codex-connector[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1144995?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: 7d82c4a5eb
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
| Beobachtete main-Basis: `c6516d4e` (Merge #1607); Arbeitsbasis ebenfalls `c6516d4e`. | ||
| Chief abwesend: PLAN-Pflege durch Root als Stellvertreter; Editor PLAN-CLEAN-4. | ||
| Quelle: Root-Auftrag PLAN-CLEAN-4 vom 16.10. (Nutzerauftrag im Root-Chat, ~03:40 MESZ); Abnahme bei Root. Ältere Z-Zeilen behalten ihr Belegdatum. | ||
| Stand: 18.10.2026 17:03 UTC (PLAN-CLEAN-5; PR-Stände per GitHub-API geprüft; Entscheidungen vom 18.10. gebucht). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The PR declares Plan-ID: PLAN-CLEAN-5, but this head has no corresponding package-table row—the maintenance table still jumps from PLAN-CLEAN-4 to PLAN-GATE. After merge, the sole plan therefore cannot state this package's goal, dependency, or completed status; add the missing row before approval.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L121-L121
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
| CODEQL-59-60 sind erledigt. Offen für dich: später dein Urteil über | ||
| die Probe-Halle (DS-H-07); die Navigationsfragen sind beantwortet (NAV-1 in der Inbox). | ||
| die Probe-Halle (DS-H-07): die Galerie-Seite ist gemergt (#1696), Bewegungsaufnahmen folgen nach | ||
| DS-H-07b (#1694); die Navigationsfragen sind beantwortet (NAV-1 in der Inbox). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
When #1694 is open as stated here, DS-H-07b needs its own package row. At this head the ID appears only in narrative references, so the canonical plan supplies no owner, dependencies, status, or acceptance criteria for the work that must produce the recordings; add the row rather than leaving the newly reported active package untracked.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L121-L121
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
Cuarroc
removed
the
review-ok
Conflict in docs/PLAN.md resolved by keeping this PR's status flips for DS-X-22/07/09 and taking the new DS-X-28 row from main unchanged. No-Test: merge of main, conflict resolution only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Conflict in docs/PLAN.md resolved by keeping this PR's rows and taking the new DS-H-07b row from main unchanged. No-Test: merge of main, conflict resolution only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
…-26 (#1705) No-Test: plan text only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…12 (#1693) No-Test: plan text only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Cuarroc
added
the
review-ok
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: 4ffae08fc7
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
| Beobachtete main-Basis: `c6516d4e` (Merge #1607); Arbeitsbasis ebenfalls `c6516d4e`. | ||
| Chief abwesend: PLAN-Pflege durch Root als Stellvertreter; Editor PLAN-CLEAN-4. | ||
| Quelle: Root-Auftrag PLAN-CLEAN-4 vom 16.10. (Nutzerauftrag im Root-Chat, ~03:40 MESZ); Abnahme bei Root. Ältere Z-Zeilen behalten ihr Belegdatum. | ||
| Stand: 18.10.2026 17:03 UTC (PLAN-CLEAN-5; PR-Stände per GitHub-API geprüft; Entscheidungen vom 18.10. gebucht). |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
At this head the plan records DS-X-32, DS-X-26, and DS-X-12 as merged, but their local merge commits are timestamped 18:30, 19:02, and 19:49 UTC respectively—after the advertised 17:03 UTC plan snapshot. The canonical plan therefore claims a verification time that cannot cover several statuses it contains; update the timestamp/provenance to the final synchronization so readers can tell when these states were actually checked.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L121-L121
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
| (NAV-0 bis NAV-2c erledigt). Beim Baukasten sind DS-X-06/07/09/11/13/22 gemergt; | ||
| die noch offenen DS-X-Pakete behalten ihre eigenen PRs und Abnahmen. Der Ablauf (Workflow) bekommt später ein Band |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
At this final head the package rows also mark DS-X-12, DS-X-26, DS-X-28, and DS-X-32 as merged, but the changed user-facing summary still names only the six packages known before those later synchronization rounds and then refers to the remaining open packages. This leaves the canonical user section stale relative to its own rows; update the summary when applying the later status flips.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L121-L121
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
|
@Mergifyio queue |
☑️ This pull request is already queued |
Merge Queue Status
This pull request spent 13 minutes 41 seconds in the queue, including 13 minutes 20 seconds running CI. Required conditions to merge
|
Der Plan zeigt die geprüften Paketstände und die Entscheidungen vom 18.10.
Die Roadmap bleibt lokal und im Dev HQ; sie wird nicht auf GitHub veröffentlicht.
Für dich ist jetzt nichts zu tun; die Abnahme der Probe-Halle folgt nach den Bewegungsaufnahmen.
Report
Plan-ID: PLAN-CLEAN-5
Operator / tier: PFLEGEN / C, plan text only. Parent / owner: Root's canonical PLAN maintenance; assigned worker, Root accepts.
Base:
f3fb146b4a63e70fee617176ae18dd6c5819a1b2(origin/main, observed again on restart).PR: #1708 (draft, base
main).Head:
7d82c4a5eb8769b64c47936287092992693512bd, branchcodex/plan-clean-5, PR basemain.Scope: only
docs/PLAN.md, 30 additions / 18 deletions, below the 300-line budget; existing unpushed commit preserved without rewriting history.Observed model: GPT-6 (system identity; no finer model identifier observed).
Native goal evidence:
get_goalreturned null at restart;create_goalthen returned an active bounded PLAN-CLEAN-5 handover goal; subsequentget_goalconfirmed it. Worker acceptance ends at verified push, draft PR and report; Root acceptance and merge remain separate.What changed
The header records PLAN-CLEAN-5, the observed main SHA and the original verification time. User-facing points 5/6 now distinguish the merged gallery from pending motion recordings and summarize the DS-X deliveries. Every changed package row is listed below; explanatory claims about delivered dependencies and gallery embedding were updated with the status.
gh pr view)claude/ds-x-06;WegWahl.tsxbleibt unberührt (KR-05a) → Erledigt: #1687 (merged 2026-10-17);WegWahl.tsxbleibt unberührt (KR-05a) #1687, MERGED 2026-10-17claude/ds-x-11; keine Bildschirmmigration, die Halle (DS-H-05) bindet die Zeile später ein → Erledigt: #1673 (merged 2026-10-17); keine Bildschirmmigration, die Halle (DS-H-05) bindet die Zeile seit #1680 ein #1673 and #1680, MERGED 2026-10-17claude/ds-x-13;Lampbleibt für Anbieter und Kontingent; die Sperrestate-tokeninscripts/ci/ratchets.jsonbleibt bei 191, weil sie--state-insrc/styles.csszählt und dieses Paket dort nichts berührt → Erledigt: #1686 (merged 2026-10-17);Lampbleibt für Anbieter und Kontingent; die Sperrestate-tokeninscripts/ci/ratchets.jsonbleibt bei 191, weil sie--state-insrc/styles.csszählt und dieses Paket dort nichts berührt #1686, MERGED 2026-10-17src/design/behauptet mehr, nicht eingebunden zu sein; der Verweis ausAGENTS.mdkommt von Root, kein Code und keine CSS-Regel ändert sich → Erledigt: #1699 (merged 2026-10-17); es gibt die beiden Anleitungen und kein Stylesheet untersrc/design/behauptet mehr, nicht eingebunden zu sein; der Verweis ausAGENTS.mdkommt von Root, kein Code und keine CSS-Regel ändert sich #1699, MERGED 2026-10-17claude/ds-x-09; keine Ansicht umgestellt (KR-07*, 10e folgen) → Erledigt: #1692 (merged 2026-10-17); keine Ansicht umgestellt (KR-07*, 10e folgen) #1692, MERGED 2026-10-17Hallzeigt gefüllt, leer und ungelesen mit Schild „Beispieldaten“, Werkstück-Kachelpiece-crate-0neu, im Register eingetragen; noch in keiner Ansicht eingebunden (Galerie DS-H-07) → Erledigt: #1663 (merged 2026-10-16);Hallzeigt gefüllt, leer und ungelesen mit Schild „Beispieldaten“, Werkstück-Kachelpiece-crate-0neu, im Register eingetragen; seit DS-H-07a (#1696, merged 2026-10-17) in der Galerie eingebunden #1663, MERGED 2026-10-16; #1696, MERGED 2026-10-17ListRow) und einen Inspektor mit der Aufgabe zuerst, eine gemeinsame Auswahl in Liste und Szene (Form und Text, nicht nur Farbe), jedes Werkstück einmal per Tastatur erreichbar; dazu die Übernahmen aus #1663 (Zustandstyp, Atlas-Schutz, Schlüssel, Tests); Halle weiter in keiner Ansicht (Galerie DS-H-07) → Erledigt: #1680 (merged 2026-10-17); die Halle zeigt neben der Szene eine Werkstück-Liste (ListRow) und einen Inspektor mit der Aufgabe zuerst, eine gemeinsame Auswahl in Liste und Szene (Form und Text, nicht nur Farbe), jedes Werkstück einmal per Tastatur erreichbar; dazu die Übernahmen aus #1663 (Zustandstyp, Atlas-Schutz, Schlüssel, Tests); Galerie mit DS-H-07a (#1696) eingebunden #1680 and #1696, MERGED 2026-10-17run), alle anderen Posen und Aus oder Betriebssystem-Bewegungsreduktion bleiben auf Bild 0, höchstens zwölf Figuren bewegen sich, ein verstecktes Dokument pausiert die Halle; die Gesten fürneed,okundbadwarten auf ein beobachtetes Wechselsignal → Erledigt: #1690 (merged 2026-10-17); es bewegt sich in Ruhig und Lebendig nur die Arbeitsfigur (run), alle anderen Posen und Aus oder Betriebssystem-Bewegungsreduktion bleiben auf Bild 0, höchstens zwölf Figuren bewegen sich, ein verstecktes Dokument pausiert die Halle; die Gesten fürneed,okundbadwarten auf ein beobachtetes Wechselsignal #1690, MERGED 2026-10-17claude/roadmap-1c-2;post-mergeerzeugt.pa/roadmap.htmlauf main neu,npm run hq:livezeigt sie unter/roadmap.html; öffentliches Hosting bleibt offene Nutzerentscheidung → Erledigt: #1659 (merged 2026-10-16), Branchclaude/roadmap-1c-2;post-mergeerzeugt.pa/roadmap.htmlauf main neu,npm run hq:livezeigt sie unter/roadmap.html; Hosting-Entscheid gebucht: ROADMAP-HOST (18.10.) #1659, MERGED 2026-10-16; ROADMAP-HOST, user order 18.10.No rows for DS-X-08/12/20/21/26/28/32 or DS-H-07b were added or changed. Historical/parser sections were preserved, except the expressly requested ROADMAP-1c-2 hosting wording. No code, HTML artifact, dependency or runtime setting changed.
Decisions recorded once
The dated block “Entscheidungen vom 18.10.2026” records the user orders relayed in the dispatch:
.pa/roadmap.htmland Dev HQ; no GitHub hosting, GitHub Pages or committed HTML. ROADMAP-1c-2 refers to the decision instead of leaving public hosting open.Evidence (2026-10-18 UTC)
bash scripts/sync.sh startgit fetch origin;git log -1 origin/mainf3fb146b4a63e70fee617176ae18dd6c5819a1b2npm run dev:start-checkbefore full prepush / before pushgh pr view <n> --json state,mergedAt,mergeCommit#103(not a package-status claim); ROADMAP #1659 checked separatelygh pr list --state open --limit 100 --json number,state,isDraft,headRefName,titlegh pr view 1706 --json number,state,headRefName,titlealso confirmed the later DS-X-20 PRplan-check.mainwithHEAD^:docs/PLAN.mdsupplied through its read dependency, current other files and live GitHubnode scripts/plan-check.mjs --offlinenode scripts/plan-check.mjsnode scripts/plan-check.mjs --jsonbefore PR creationgit diff origin/main...HEAD --checkgit diff origin/main...HEAD --statbash scripts/ci/secret-scan.shbash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush7d82c4a5, all 28 gates green, 584 s; Rust 2278 passed / 7 skipped; Denkraum browser 33 passedgit push -u origin codex/plan-clean-5gh pr create --draft --base main --head codex/plan-clean-5 --title <requested title> --body-file <prepared body>gh pr view 1708 --json url,state,isDraft,headRefOid,baseRefName,filesbash scripts/sync.sh note codex <handover>git ls-remote origin refs/heads/codex/plan-clean-57d82c4a5eb8769b64c47936287092992693512bdThe first run's historical handover recorded 14 → 6 online findings. The restart independently reproduced the same eight removed contradictions as 15 → 7; the later DS-X-20 opening raises only the excluded missing-row count to eight. Online exit 1 is reported unchanged, not hidden. No stale-PR finding remains for any touched row. The explicit prohibition on editing those eight package rows takes precedence over making the global online count zero. The new maintenance PR itself has no added package row, as required by the no-new-rows scope; later online checks can consequently also list this PR as missing a row.
NICHT ABGEDECKT
#[cfg(windows)]tests (run_in_pty, npm_shim, ConPTY, DPAPI) or Windows clippy arms; the Windows lane runs in the merge queue.linuxlane: app browser smoke, frontend build and workflow gates are outside this run.--eventsjob audit, usage-file check or worker-output observation was supplied. Thelage-jetztworktree mirror is unavailable; live Git/GitHub sources were used.Reviews and disposition
Review: ausstehend (Stufe C); pending, Root commissions. Tier C requires gates; Root accepts. This worker performed no independent review, set no labels and did not queue or merge the PR.
Handover
State: implemented, committed, locally tested and pushed with verified remote SHA; draft PR handed to Root. Root acceptance, ready state, queue integration and merge remain open. Existing startcheck blockage was cleared by a fresh passing check; the previous commit is preserved. Root owns the next acceptance/integration step and the eight excluded packages retain their own PRs and acceptance duties. No additional implementation is needed within this package's scope.
🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Root acceptance (head 7d82c4a)
Tier C (docs/PLAN.md only, 30+/18-). Gates suffice per AGENTS.md rule 5; Root (Anthropic, not the author family OpenAI) accepts.
Checked by Root: only docs/PLAN.md changed; no row of an open package PR touched; decision block ROADMAP-HOST / OPS-18-1 / OPS-18-2 matches Elias's orders of 18.10.; worker prepush exit 0 at head 7d82c4a; remaining online plan-check findings are only the open package PRs that carry their own rows.
The feeder's optional Claude review of this head is informational for tier C. review-ok is bound to 7d82c4a.
Conflict resolution (18.10.)
origin/mainatac408f688aee9439b9a933e4b607386a62768522(includes feat(design): DS-X-28 toast queue #1704, DS-X-28) intocodex/plan-clean-5; merge commit, no rebase, no force-push.docs/PLAN.md: kept this PR's status flips for DS-X-22, DS-X-07 and DS-X-09 (main had not changed those three rows) and took the new DS-X-28 row from main unchanged. The DS-X-28 row is not flipped. All other PR changes (Stand line, status flips, block "Entscheidungen vom 18.10.2026", ROADMAP-1c-2 wording) are untouched.docs/PLAN.md(git diff origin/main...HEAD --stat: 1 file, 30+/18-).7d82c4a5eb8769b64c47936287092992693512bd; new head712bd2b72dcf3e72fc186b0ff4db385ea8cf212e(verified withgit ls-remote origin codex/plan-clean-5).git merge origin/main(one conflict, resolved by hand)node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offlinebash scripts/ci/secret-scan.shbash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane precommit(via commit hook)bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushgit push -u origin codex/plan-clean-5(pre-push hook re-ran prepush)Commit trailer:
No-Test: merge of main, conflict resolution only. NICHT ABGEDECKT: the#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows arm of clippy (Linux run only). The Root acceptance above is bound to the old head7d82c4a5; Root re-checks the resolution delta. Review: ausstehend (Stufe C). Not marked ready, no label, not queued.🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Second sync (18.10.)
While the first resolution was being pushed, #1694 (DS-H-07b) merged into
mainas3d9abbe27aa9aabf85ed44b826e8db3643470cb9and conflicted again indocs/PLAN.md. Hunk: main only added the new DS-H-07b row between DS-H-07 and DS-H-07a; the five neighbouring rows are this PR's versions. Resolved mechanically: kept this PR's rows, inserted main's DS-H-07b row unchanged at main's position (no content decision, row not flipped).3d9abbe27aa9aabf85ed44b826e8db3643470cb9; files touched: onlydocs/PLAN.md(git diff origin/main...HEAD --stat: 1 file, 30+/18-).712bd2b72dcf3e72fc186b0ff4db385ea8cf212e; new head278aa565978bbb8ce6894026ef5274e2e876d371(verified withgit ls-remote origin codex/plan-clean-5). The first-sync head above is superseded.node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offlineexit 0;bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushexit 0 (no red gate); commit hook precommit lane exit 0;git push -u origin codex/plan-clean-5exit 0 (pre-push hook re-ran prepush). Trailer:No-Test: merge of main, conflict resolution only.Conflict resolution and live update 3 (18.10.)
4a9c8a5b156704c3ea11b7a2dfa40911e55234f4(feat(design): DS-X-32 viz palette #1702 DS-X-32). The only conflict was indocs/PLAN.md(main still carried the stale DS-X-22/DS-X-07/DS-X-09 rows from before this PR's earlier flips). Resolution keeps this branch's flipped rows and main's DS-X-32 row, now flipped too.gh pr view <n> --json state,mergedAt):#1696/#1694.plan-checktreats a pending status whose cited PRs are all merged asstatus-contradicts-github(observed with the ordered wording: 2 findings, DS-H-07 feat(design): DS-H-07a probe hall gallery page #1696/feat(dev): DS-H-07b shot.mjs motion, dpr and video #1694); the PR numbers stay in the DS-H-07a and DS-H-07b rows.83d16689d1ed99acab5c00414a4f63a7a926c58c(verified withgit ls-remote origin codex/plan-clean-5). Trailer:No-Test: plan text only(merge and flips are in one merge commit).node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offlineexit 0 (0 findings); onlinenode scripts/plan-check.mjsexit 1 with 7 findings, allpr-without-plan-rowfor open PRs feat(design): DS-X-16 gallery stories controls and inputs #1712, docs(plan): PLAN-CLEAN-5 live status and decisions of 18.10. #1708, feat(design): DS-X-20 icon button, loading, link tabs #1706, feat(design): DS-X-26 popover #1705, feat(design): DS-X-21 icon set #1701, feat(design): DS-X-08 confirm dialog #1700, feat(design): DS-X-12 apply motion tokens #1693 (their titles carry no Plan-ID, unchanged by this PR), nostatus-contradicts-githubfor any row touched;git diff origin/main...HEAD --stat: onlydocs/PLAN.md(33+/21-);bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.shexit 0;bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushexit 0 (514 s);git push -u origin codex/plan-clean-5exit 0.#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows clippy arms (Linux run; the Windows lane runs in the merge queue). Review: pending, Root commissions (tier C, gates only).🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Root acceptance (head 4ffae08, 18.10. ~23:10 MESZ)
docs/PLAN.md(+35/-23). Tier C (plan text, no runtime effect): gates suffice, no external review required.priorityso it merges before further DS merges (ends the PLAN conflict churn).