Repository navigation
feat(design): DS-X-21 icon set - #1701
Conversation
The brief's test name has a comma, which the commit-msg hook rejects in a Test-First trailer; the test reads 'and is hidden' instead. Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::every registered icon renders a 20 px svg and is hidden unless labelled Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::an empty label stays hidden Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::has an equivalent for every classic glyph and every route glyph Test-First: src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts::THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES lists Lucide and the licence file exists Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Icon renders 24 Lucide paths copied as data (ISC and Feather MIT notice shipped as LUCIDE-LIZENZ.txt), with stand-ins for the classic, route and Select glyphs. No caller migrates; the classic Icon stays until KR-15. Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::every registered icon renders a 20 px svg and is hidden unless labelled Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::an empty label stays hidden Test-First: src/design/icons/icon.test.tsx::has an equivalent for every classic glyph and every route glyph Test-First: src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts::THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES lists Lucide and the licence file exists Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
No-Test: plan text only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
No-Test: merge of main, conflict resolution only Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…ns page (R1701-ROOT1, R1701-F1) No-Test: adds coverage for existing behaviour (review R1701-F1) Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
…t (R1701-L1) Test-First: src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts::a Vite build ships the glyph paths together with both copyright notices Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
…s a legal comment (R1701-L1) Regression-For: 77c3cfb Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
# Conflicts: # docs/PLAN.md
… runs on Windows (R1701-T1)
execFileSync("npx") without a shell cannot start the npx.cmd wrapper on
Windows. Run process.execPath with node_modules/vite/bin/vite.js instead.
Regression-For: 77c3cfb
Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
No-Test: merge commit, docs/PLAN.md conflict only Co-Authored-By: GPT-6 <noreply@openai.com>
Codex Review SummaryThis comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHubYour team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: d2ab6aadb8
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
| | DS-X-08 | Bestätigungsdialog `ConfirmDialog` (`role="alertdialog"`, Fokus zuerst auf Abbrechen, Esc bricht ab, ein Klick auf den Hintergrund schließt nicht, Bestätigen löst nur einmal aus, Gefahr-Ton über `Button` „danger“) und `Sheet` mit Größe (`sm`/`md`/`lg`) sowie Beschriftungs- und Beschreibungs-Kennungen; bestehende `Sheet`-Aufrufer bleiben unverändert; noch an keine Ansicht angeschlossen (jedes Paket, das ihn an Löschen, Zusammenführen oder Überschreiben hängt, ist Stufe A) | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-07 (#1683); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-08) | Server | B | In Arbeit: Draft-PR `claude/ds-x-08` | red-first Vitest-Tests; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bildschirmfotos hell/dunkel; ein unabhängiger Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie (Root beauftragt) | – | | ||
| | DS-X-09 | Tabelle v2 (Fabrik-Designsystem, Welle 1): `src/design/data/Table.tsx` bekommt sortierbare Spaltenköpfe (`aria-sort`, Enter und Leertaste), optionale Zeilenauswahl mit dem Ankreuzfeld (Kopf-Feld „teils“, Anzahl wird angesagt), eine feststehende Kopfzeile sowie Platzhalter für leer und lädt über `HonestState`; bestehende Aufrufer bleiben unverändert | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-05 (#1678); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-09) | Server | B | Erledigt: #1692 (merged 2026-10-17); keine Ansicht umgestellt (KR-07*, 10e folgen) | Tests rot→grün (`red-first.sh` Exit 0); `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bildschirmfotos hell/dunkel; ein Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie, Root kommissioniert | – | | ||
| | DS-X-12 | Bewegungstoken angewendet: ein Druck-Token (`--g-press-scale`) für Knöpfe, Filterchips, Segmente und Tabs; der Füllbalken wächst per `transform: scaleX()` statt über die Breite, die Erlaubnisliste für Layout-Animation in `motion.test.ts` ist leer; der Lauf-Ring atmet nur unter `--g-ambient-play` (Lebendig), in Ruhig steht er still und ein Zustandswechsel gibt einen einmaligen Ping (`usePulseOnChange`); eine dokumentierte Regel für reduzierte Bewegung am Kopf von `motion.css`; das doppelte `g-enter` entfällt | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-03 (#1606), DS-X-07 (#1683); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-12) | Server | B | Erledigt: #1693 (merged 2026-10-18) | red-first Vitest-Tests; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, contrast-check, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; ein unabhängiger Stufe-B-Review (Root beauftragt) | – | | ||
| | DS-X-21 | Ein Symbolsatz auf 20-px-Raster: `Icon` in `src/design/icons/` (ohne Beschriftung für Hilfstechnik verborgen, mit `label` als `role="img"`, Farbe über `currentColor`) und 24 Lucide-Pfade als Daten (`glyphs.ts`), dazu Entsprechungen für die 14 klassischen Symbole, die Seitenleisten-Symbole und den Auswahl-Pfeil; Lizenztext `LUCIDE-LIZENZ.txt` neben den Symbolen und Eintrag in `docs/THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md` | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (DS-X-21), Root-Entscheidung 17.10.: Pfade kopieren, kein Paket | Server | B + Lizenzprüfung | Entwurfs-PR offen (17.10.): kein Aufrufer umgestellt, `src/components/Icon.tsx` bleibt bis KR-15; Galerie zeigt den Satz unter „Symbole“ | Tests rot→grün; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bilder der Galerie hell und dunkel; ein Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie, Root prüft den Lizenzhinweis | – | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Require both tier-B reviewer paths
For this frontend TypeScript package, the acceptance field requires only one non-author review, so following the newly added row can grant review-ok with only half of the required coverage. Tier B requires two different non-author families—one subscription reviewer and one eligible OpenRouter reviewer—and free feedback does not count; update the row and obtain both qualifying verdicts before acceptance.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L320-L326
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
| | DS-X-08 | Bestätigungsdialog `ConfirmDialog` (`role="alertdialog"`, Fokus zuerst auf Abbrechen, Esc bricht ab, ein Klick auf den Hintergrund schließt nicht, Bestätigen löst nur einmal aus, Gefahr-Ton über `Button` „danger“) und `Sheet` mit Größe (`sm`/`md`/`lg`) sowie Beschriftungs- und Beschreibungs-Kennungen; bestehende `Sheet`-Aufrufer bleiben unverändert; noch an keine Ansicht angeschlossen (jedes Paket, das ihn an Löschen, Zusammenführen oder Überschreiben hängt, ist Stufe A) | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-07 (#1683); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-08) | Server | B | In Arbeit: Draft-PR `claude/ds-x-08` | red-first Vitest-Tests; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bildschirmfotos hell/dunkel; ein unabhängiger Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie (Root beauftragt) | – | | ||
| | DS-X-09 | Tabelle v2 (Fabrik-Designsystem, Welle 1): `src/design/data/Table.tsx` bekommt sortierbare Spaltenköpfe (`aria-sort`, Enter und Leertaste), optionale Zeilenauswahl mit dem Ankreuzfeld (Kopf-Feld „teils“, Anzahl wird angesagt), eine feststehende Kopfzeile sowie Platzhalter für leer und lädt über `HonestState`; bestehende Aufrufer bleiben unverändert | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-05 (#1678); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-09) | Server | B | Erledigt: #1692 (merged 2026-10-17); keine Ansicht umgestellt (KR-07*, 10e folgen) | Tests rot→grün (`red-first.sh` Exit 0); `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bildschirmfotos hell/dunkel; ein Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie, Root kommissioniert | – | | ||
| | DS-X-12 | Bewegungstoken angewendet: ein Druck-Token (`--g-press-scale`) für Knöpfe, Filterchips, Segmente und Tabs; der Füllbalken wächst per `transform: scaleX()` statt über die Breite, die Erlaubnisliste für Layout-Animation in `motion.test.ts` ist leer; der Lauf-Ring atmet nur unter `--g-ambient-play` (Lebendig), in Ruhig steht er still und ein Zustandswechsel gibt einen einmaligen Ping (`usePulseOnChange`); eine dokumentierte Regel für reduzierte Bewegung am Kopf von `motion.css`; das doppelte `g-enter` entfällt | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-X-03 (#1606), DS-X-07 (#1683); DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (Zeile DS-X-12) | Server | B | Erledigt: #1693 (merged 2026-10-18) | red-first Vitest-Tests; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, contrast-check, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; ein unabhängiger Stufe-B-Review (Root beauftragt) | – | | ||
| | DS-X-21 | Ein Symbolsatz auf 20-px-Raster: `Icon` in `src/design/icons/` (ohne Beschriftung für Hilfstechnik verborgen, mit `label` als `role="img"`, Farbe über `currentColor`) und 24 Lucide-Pfade als Daten (`glyphs.ts`), dazu Entsprechungen für die 14 klassischen Symbole, die Seitenleisten-Symbole und den Auswahl-Pfeil; Lizenztext `LUCIDE-LIZENZ.txt` neben den Symbolen und Eintrag in `docs/THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md` | Implementierer · Claude; Root nimmt ab | DS-Blueprint-Schnitt 16.10. (DS-X-21), Root-Entscheidung 17.10.: Pfade kopieren, kein Paket | Server | B + Lizenzprüfung | Entwurfs-PR offen (17.10.): kein Aufrufer umgestellt, `src/components/Icon.tsx` bleibt bis KR-15; Galerie zeigt den Satz unter „Symbole“ | Tests rot→grün; `vitest run src/design`, typecheck, `contrast-check`, `plan-check --offline` und prepush Exit 0; Bilder der Galerie hell und dunkel; ein Stufe-B-Review einer Nicht-Anthropic-Familie, Root prüft den Lizenzhinweis | – | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Record the post-merge DS-X-21 status
At the reviewed head, this commit already delivers the icon set, yet its new plan row still says that the draft PR is open. That status becomes false as soon as the change merges, leaving the canonical plan stale; replace it with the delivered post-merge state and merge/PR reference.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L121-L121
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
| focusable="false" | ||
| className={className} | ||
| style={{ display: "block", flexShrink: 0, ...style }} | ||
| {...rest} |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Prevent callers from overriding fixed icon attributes
When a caller supplies an otherwise valid SVGProps field such as stroke, strokeWidth, viewBox, or fill, this late spread overwrites the component's fixed Lucide contract. For example, <Icon name="check" stroke="red" /> no longer follows currentColor, despite both the component documentation and registry promising that behavior; either spread rest before the fixed attributes or omit these fields from IconProps.
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
Merge Queue Status
This pull request spent 8 minutes 40 seconds in the queue, including 7 minutes 55 seconds running CI. Required conditions to merge
|
Das Designsystem hat jetzt einen einzigen Symbolsatz: 24 Lucide-Symbole auf einem 20-Pixel-Raster, mit einer Icon-Komponente, die ohne Beschriftung für Vorlese-Hilfen verborgen ist. Die Symbole stehen als kopierte Pfade im Code (kein Paket installiert), der Lizenztext liegt daneben und ist in den Drittanbieter-Hinweisen eingetragen. Keine Ansicht wurde umgestellt; die alte Icon-Komponente bleibt bis KR-15, und die Galerie zeigt den Satz unter „Symbole“.
Report
Plan-ID: DS-X-21
Change
src/design/icons/Icon.tsx: oneIcon(20 px, Lucide's 24-unit viewBox, strokecurrentColor). Nolabel:aria-hidden. Withlabel:role="img"andaria-label. An empty label stays hidden.src/design/icons/glyphs.ts: 24 Lucide paths as data (each glyph an array of path strings; rect, circle and line turned into paths), plusCLASSIC_GLYPH(14 classic glyphs ofsrc/components/Icon.tsx) andROUTE_GLYPH(the 10 sidebar glyphs ofsrc/shell/routes.ts, one more than the brief's nine: leitstand, eingang, beweise, betrieb, team, automatik, core, steuerung, gedaechtnis, einstellungen). The Select chevron ischevron-down.src/design/icons/LUCIDE-LIZENZ.txtis the unmodified LucideLICENSE(ISC, "Copyright (c) 2026 Lucide Icons and Contributors", plus the Feather MIT notice, Cole Bemis), fetched from https://raw.githubusercontent.com/lucide-icons/lucide/main/LICENSE (https://github.com/lucide-icons/lucide/blob/main/LICENSE). Entry under "Required notices" indocs/THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md. Paths copied fromicons/<name>.svgin the same repository.Icon(new familyicons,gallery.family.icons= "Symbole" inde.ts); the gallery family page "Symbole" shows all glyphs with their names (5 lines inGallery.tsx, 1 CSS line).docs/PLAN.md: one row DS-X-21.Red → green
97a788a9(compiling stubs plus tests): 4 of 4 tests failed (npx vitest run src/design/icons). Commit738254a3makes them green.every registered icon renders a 20 px svg, hidden unless labelledcontains a comma, which the commit-msg hook rejects in a Test-First trailer. The test is named... renders a 20 px svg and is hidden unless labelled.Evidence (all unmasked)
npx vitest run src/design src/i18n: 46 files, 238 tests, exit 0.npm run typecheck: exit 0.node scripts/contrast-check.mjs: 760 pairs passed, exit 0.node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline: 0 findings, exit 0.bash scripts/ci/red-first.sh: exit 0.bash scripts/ci/license-check.sh: exit 0 (12 production packages, all on the allowlist; the gate does not see copied paths, hence the notice entry).bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush(own worktree,CARGO_TARGET_DIRslot2,CARGO_BUILD_JOBS=1): exit 0, all 28 gates green.git ls-remote origin claude/ds-x-21=dbe5dc9f.#/designsystem› Symbole, scratch script outside the repo; looked at, all 24 glyphs sharp in both):/home/pa/pa-orch/reports/ds-x-21-light.png,/home/pa/pa-orch/reports/ds-x-21-dark.png.Architecture drift: no new finding, nothing allowlisted. No seam touched.
NICHT ABGEDECKT
#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows arms of clippy (Linux run only); the Windows lane runs in the merge queue.linux, CI).Iconyet.Review: pending, Root commissions (tier B plus licence check, one independent non-Anthropic reviewer).
🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Conflict resolution (18.10.)
origin/mainatf3fb146bintoclaude/ds-x-21(merge commit, no rebase, no force-push). New head:7288411d.docs/PLAN.md(rows DS-X-21 and DS-X-09),src/design/gallery/Gallery.tsx(iconspage andhallprobe-hall page; imports of both),src/i18n/de.ts(probe-hall keys from main plusgallery.family.icons). No other edit.npx vitest run src/design src/i18n→ 0 (49 files, 252 tests)npm run typecheck→ 0node scripts/contrast-check.mjs→ 0node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0git diff origin/main...HEAD --stat→ only this PR's 11 filesbash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush→ 0 (third run)git ls-remote origin claude/ds-x-21→7288411dfe-testonly on time limits under heavy server load (load average 40+ on 8 cores):boot.smoke.test.tsx(1 swaitForon the cold first import),Shell.test.tsx,renderBudget.test.tsx.boot.smokefails the same way on a pristineorigin/maincheckout and passes once the load drops; no test or timeout was changed.#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows clippy arms (Windows lane runs in the merge queue). Review: pending, Root commissions (delta check of the resolution).Review round 1 (18.10.)
Review: Codex gpt-6-astra (OpenAI), verdict "approve with conditions". Delta check of the fix: pending, Root commissions (tier B).
default:branch inBodyofGallery.tsxlost its indentationObject.keys(GLYPHS).length, each cell has an svg). The test was green at once (existing behaviour), so it carries a No-Test trailer on the commitb3c4900d59519fe71d5557a500bb2851953a80cc(verified withgit ls-remote origin claude/ds-x-21)git diff origin/main...HEAD --shortstat→ 12 files, 210 insertions, 1 deletion (≤400)npx vitest run src/design/gallery→ 0 (11 tests)npm run typecheck→ 0;node scripts/contrast-check.mjs→ 0;node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0;bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.sh→ 0bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush→ 0 (532 s, unmasked); push hook green,git push→ 0#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows clippy arms (Windows lane runs in the merge queue).Review round 2 (18.10.)
77c3cfbd(red), fix commit3b3a3abd: the full notice fromLUCIDE-LIZENZ.txtis a/*! … */legal comment aboveGLYPHSinsrc/design/icons/glyphs.ts. Smallest robust way: no new file, no config change; the bundler keeps/*!comments next to the glyph chunk, and the test proves it.vite.config.tsandtauri.conf.jsonare untouched.src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts"a Vite build ships the glyph paths together with both copyright notices" runsnpx vite build --outDir <tmp>and requiresM9.671 4.136a2.34,Lucide Icons and ContributorsandCole Bemisin the output.npx vitest run src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts→ exit 1 onb3c4900d, exit 0 after the fix. The first test also checks that the comment inglyphs.tsrepeatsLUCIDE-LIZENZ.txtline for line (no drift).mainhad moved and the PR was CONFLICTING (onlydocs/PLAN.md, the DS-X-32 row next to DS-X-21): mergedorigin/main(merge commit, both rows kept).603834a17b37450d8b603c1e355e8c75b080f097(verified withgit ls-remote origin claude/ds-x-21).git diff origin/main...HEAD --shortstat→ 12 files, 280 insertions, 1 deletion (≤400, forced fix round; L1 added about 70 lines incl. the notice comment and test).npx vitest run src/design→ 0 (48 files, 239 tests);npm run typecheck→ 0;node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0;bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.sh→ 0.bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushon the merged head → 0 (434 s, unmasked);git push→ 0.#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows clippy arms (Windows lane runs in the merge queue); the build check ran on Linux only; the Tauri installer bundle itself was not built (only the Vite output).🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Review round 3 (18.10.)
npxviaexecFileSyncwithout a shell; on Windows thenpx.cmdwrapper cannot be started that way, so Windows prepushfe-testfails before the licence is checked.2f0c300d: the test now startsprocess.execPathwithnode_modules/vite/bin/vite.jsand the same arguments (nonpx, no shell). Marked as a regression fix of the round-2 test commit77c3cfbd.src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts, +3 / -1 lines; L1 stays confirmed fixed.2f0c300d7f5d74bf3a69cca5a351c94dc8683887(verified withgit ls-remote origin claude/ds-x-21).git diff origin/main...HEAD --shortstat→ 12 files, 282 insertions, 1 deletion. The PR was MERGEABLE, so no merge ofmainwas needed.npx vitest run src/design/icons/icons.notice.test.ts→ 0 (2 tests);npm run typecheck→ 0;node scripts/contrast-check.mjs→ 0;node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0;bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.sh→ 0.bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush→ 0 (221 files, 1644 tests, unmasked). The first run exited 1:src/screens/leitstand/perf/renderBudget.test.tsxhit its 5000 ms timeout while the server load average was about 35 on 8 cores; alone the file passes (exit 0, 1 s). The second run, with no test or code change, was green.git push→ 0 (the pre-push hook ran).crlf-source-comparescans git-ignored folders under.pa/and flagged an old review checkout (review-pr1701-red-77c3cfbd) inside this worktree. It was moved, not deleted and not modified, to a sibling folder outside the repo; the other two folders under.pa/were left in place.nodewithvite.js) was not run here; the Windows lane runs in the merge queue. Also not covered: the#[cfg(windows)]tests and the Windows clippy arms; the Tauri installer bundle was not built.🤖 Generated with Claude Code on the ProjectA server worker
Conflict fix (Codex, 2026-10-20)
origin/mainata4ef7057699afa559e14028ef200432b3459e7b2; no rebase, force-push, product edits or review fixes.2f0c300d7f5d74bf3a69cca5a351c94dc8683887. Merge/new remote head:d2ab6aadb8ef7be7cca02b0c0b6377cd5021711e.docs/PLAN.mdwas the only conflicted file. Kept the entire main PLAN byte-for-byte and inserted the exact branch-only DS-X-21 row once. An assertion-based comparison also confirmed unchanged added/deleted lines for every original PR file (exit 0). No seam touched.No-Test: merge commit, docs/PLAN.md conflict only; co-author GPT-6 (system-provided identity; a more specific harness model ID is not exposed in this session).Evidence (2026-10-20, exit codes preserved)
git rev-parse HEADbefore work: exit 0, old head above; clean worktree.git fetch origin: exit 0.git merge origin/main: exit 1 for the expected PLAN-only conflict; resolved and committed using the exact requested merge message and identity, exit 0. The commit hook passed all 14 precommit gates (94 s).npm ci: exit 0 (node_modules was absent).node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline: exit 0, 0 Befunde.git diff origin/main...HEAD --stat: exit 0; the same original 12 PR files, 282 insertions / 1 deletion, including exactly one added PLAN row.bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.shbefore commit: exit 0, no leaks; also passed in the commit hook.bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush: exit 0 on the first run, 536 s, inC:/Users/Cuarr/orca/ProjectA/.claude/worktrees/codex-dsx21, HEADd2ab6aad.CARGO_TARGET_DIR=C:/Users/Cuarr/cargo-targets/projecta-b,CARGO_BUILD_JOBS=1; no CARGO_PROFILE override. Frontend: 225 files / 1674 tests passed. Rust: 2319 passed, 20 skipped.git push origin HEAD:claude/ds-x-21: exit 0.git ls-remote origin refs/heads/claude/ds-x-21: exit 0, full new head above.gh pr view 1701 --json headRefOid,mergeable,mergeStateStatus,isDraft,labels,url: exit 0; new head confirmed,MERGEABLE, draft remains true. The existingconflictlabel was still present at this observation; labels were not changed.NICHT ABGEDECKT
#[cfg(unix)]tests (file permissions / process-group kill) or Linux clippy arms. Existing platform/capability skips remain; no skip, assertion, retry or timeout was changed.shellcheckandactionlintare not installed locally; the gates explicitly skipped them. This run does not prove those checks.Disposition / handover: conflict-fix acceptance passed and push verified. Existing reviews are unchanged; Root owns any remaining acceptance/integration. No ready/draft transition, label edit, merge or Mergify queue comment was performed. Native bounded goal was created after
get_goalreturned null; parent integration remains with Root.Root acceptance after conflict fix (Root, 2026-10-20)
Head
d2ab6aad= round-3 head2f0c300d+ merge oforigin/main(docs/PLAN.md only). Root check: product diff vs main excluding docs/PLAN.md is line-for-line identical to2f0c300d(PRODUCT-DIFF-IDENTICAL); plan-check 0 Befunde; Codex prepush exit 0 (536 s) and push hook exit 0.Round-3 delta (
icons.notice.test.ts+3/−1, Claude-authored) was still owed a non-author review; it is covered by the full-PR review below.Second non-author family (author Anthropic): NVIDIA nemotron-3-ultra (free kilo lane) on
d2ab6aad: APPROVE WITH CONDITIONS.Decision: families OpenAI (server Codex, rounds 1–3) and NVIDIA have reviewed; no open high finding.
review-okbound tod2ab6aad.