Repository navigation
docs: add the v2.0 rest order and the GI05 answer to PLAN - #1918
Conversation
Add the V2-REST section with rows for the Glass rest, V2-ACC1b-NEW, V2-SHOT-BASE-PREP, V2-UAT-1a-NEW and V2-REL-PREP, the open endcard in the decision inbox and the GI05 answer of 26.10.2026 (hide the 13 unconnected Glass areas by default, visible persistent switch). Correct the KR-08c-2b-LIVE row to the evidenced merge (#1915, 5c15cdd). Plan-ID: V2-REST-PLAN-PFLEGEN No-Test: docs-only plan rows and recorded user decision Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Codex Review SummaryThis comment shows the latest Codex review activity on this pull request.
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHubYour team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
Codex reacts with 👀 while any review is running, comments if it has suggestions, and reacts with 👍 once all reviews finish with no findings. |
![chatgpt-codex-connector[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/1144995?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
💡 Codex Review
Here are some automated review suggestions for this pull request.
Reviewed commit: 36e868eb97
ℹ️ About Codex in GitHub
Your team has set up Codex to review pull requests in this repo. Reviews are triggered when you
- Open a pull request for review
- Mark a draft as ready
- Comment "@codex review".
If Codex has suggestions, it will comment; otherwise it will react with 👍.
Codex can also answer questions or update the PR. Try commenting "@codex address that feedback".
|
|
||
| | ID | Ziel | Owner | Hängt ab von | Ort | Stufe | Status | Abnahme | Ticket | | ||
| |---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---| | ||
| | V2-REST-PLAN-PFLEGEN | Kurze kanonische Restreihenfolge mit Owner und Abhängigkeiten, GI05-Entscheid und Mergestatus von KR-08c-2b-LIVE nachführen | srv-v2-rest-plan-pflegen; Stabs delegiert, Root nimmt ab | KR-08c-2b-LIVE | Server | C | In Prüfung: Entwurf-PR, nur diese Datei | Reine Dokumentation (No-Test). Vollständige KR-Inventur im PR-Report, nicht im Repo. Keine Produkt-, native, installiert/wirksam- oder UAT-Abnahme und keine neue Freigabe | f13918cc-fc43-409e-90c6-7ef235fa7132 | |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Die im Commit als Plan-ID benannte Zeile bleibt auf „In Prüfung: Entwurf-PR“ stehen. Nach dem Merge würde der kanonische Plan damit dieses bereits gelieferte Dokumentationspaket weiterhin als offenen Entwurf ausweisen; außerdem hängt V2-REST-GLASS ausdrücklich davon ab. Die verbindliche Review-Regel aus AGENTS.md verlangt über den eingebundenen Abschnitt „Reviews and advisors“, dass die eigene Planzeile den Zustand nach dem Merge beschreibt. Bitte den Status entsprechend bedingt formulieren, etwa „Erledigt mit Root-Abnahme und Merge dieses Dokumentenschnitts“, ohne damit Produkt- oder Nutzerabnahmen zu behaupten.
AGENTS.md reference: AGENTS.md:L74-L76
Useful? React with 👍 / 👎.
|
@Cuarroc Dieser PR hat einen Konflikt mit main und kann nicht in die Merge-Queue. Bitte main hineinmergen (kein Rebase, kein Force-Push) und den Konflikt loesen; das Label |
Merge origin/main (be8b703, #1917) to resolve the real PLAN.md conflict at the KR-08c-2b-LIVE / FU-KR08C-LIVE-PLACEMENT rows; both rows are kept. Correct the V2-REST rows: own status after merge, #1917 merged with its actual SHA, RESTORE next on a fresh base, exited-tab eligibility as a separate residual, KR-07a parking kept in the 07a-11c-11d chain, GI05 runs independently of RESTORE. Record the bounded Root acceptance of #1915 and #1917 and the GI05 answer versus the accepted conservative cut. Plan-ID: V2-REST-PLAN-PFLEGEN No-Test: docs-only plan correction, no runtime or test change Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 5.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Cuarroc
added
the
review-ok
|
@Mergifyio queue |
|
Disposition correction (Root, 2026-10-26T03:30:01Z) after PM note: Chief finding P3 (PLAN:279/:502 wording 'nichts davon geliefert, getestet, abgenommen oder gemergt' about the GI05 draft) is NOT fixed in this head eb9e380. It is a remaining wording rest: follow-up for the PLAN owner (Stabschef) in the next PLAN-PFLEGEN package, to restate the GI05 state per stage (delivered/tested/reviewed/accepted/merged) once #1919 settles. No new push; Tier C docs; queue position unchanged. |
Merge Queue Status
This pull request spent 8 minutes 44 seconds in the queue, including 8 minutes 2 seconds running CI. Required conditions to merge
|
Dieser Entwurf ergänzt den Plan um die kurze Reihenfolge bis zur v2.0.0-Abnahme: Glass-Rest, technische Abnahme, Bilder, Klick-Checkliste, Release-Entwurf und die noch offene Endkarte für dich. Außerdem steht deine Antwort zu den 13 nicht angeschlossenen Bereichen im Plan (standardmäßig verbergen, per sichtbarem Schalter wieder zeigen), und der gemergte Stand von KR-08c-2b-LIVE ist berichtigt. Es ist nur Dokumentation: nichts wurde gebaut, installiert, im Programm geprüft oder freigegeben, und die Release-Sperre bleibt bestehen.
Plan-ID: V2-REST-PLAN-PFLEGEN
Report
Package / tier: V2-REST-PLAN-PFLEGEN, tier C (docs only), single file
docs/PLAN.md. No-Test trailer: documentation of the accepted v2.0 rest order and recorded user decisions. Draft PR; first commit36e868eb, correction round adds the merge/correction commiteb9e380d(see "Nachbesserung").Model / admission: runtime init states
claude-sonnet-5-5(Claude subscription, not claude-api). Requested efforthigh; the runtime does not expose an actual effort field, so none is claimed. Dispatcher quota read 2026-10-26T01:06:42Z (Claude weekly 46%, session 5%, no error); admission file SHA-2567fc40a17…94dfeeverified at start 2026-10-26T01:10Z (inside 60 min). No extra agents, reviewers, QA or services started.Base:
origin/main=5c15cddeccf6e0ab8333f2c72326cc94223c263eat start, before write and before push (git rev-parse origin/main), main CI at that SHA: ci, dev-build, test-insights = success. Worktree was clean. No exact duplicate: no PR was open at start; #1917 (FU-KR08C-LIVE-PLACEMENT, Codex, draft) appeared during the work and touches the same filedocs/PLAN.mdas this PR, in different agreed regions (its own KR/FU rows vs. the V2-REST section and the inbox). It has since merged (see "Nachbesserung").What changed (
docs/PLAN.md, +18/−3 raw lines)msg-0mvoiks7e-9f5929ea, native 00:24:13.514Z, user ca. 00:23Z). Only the GI05 part (2.) is applied; process cleanup (1.) is recorded as Root history, not worker permission; the new-native-admission process-exception list stays empty.5c15cdde…, main CI success); "Root acceptance not evidenced". Meaning of the other cells unchanged.docs/plan/v2.0/plan.mdwas only read.KR 10.2 live inventory (26.10.2026; full per-row file kept outside the repo, not committed)
gh pr list --state all --search 'KR-' --limit 1000→ 25 PRs (exit 0, below limit, no pagination gap). GitHub search matches text, so it was cross-checked withgh pr list --state all --limit 3000(1913 PRs, max merge queue: checking #1915 on main (f060314) #1916) and a local title/branch filter: 18 KR PRs, 2 not found by the search (fix: preserve truthful empty-terminal launch failures #1911, test: strengthen public terminal launch regression evidence #1913, noKR-in the title); the search also matched 9 unrelated PRs by body text (feat(denkraum): serve canonical design-system CSS bundle (DN-01) #1549, docs: sync October 15 plan and review rules (DOC-SYNC-2) #1557, feat(plan): shared model and freshness check (PLAN-AUTO-1) #1564, fix(design): DS-T-05 main view offers the first step #1629, feat(design): DS-X-06 RadioGroup and SwitchField #1687, feat(design): DS-X-09 table v2 #1692, feat(design): DS-X-21 icon set #1701, docs(plan): PLAN-CLEAN-5 live status and decisions of 18.10. #1708, feat(plan): PLAN-AUTO-2 plan:sync rewrites stale status cells #1711), not counted as delivery proof. All merge commits of done rows are ancestors oforigin/main(git merge-base --is-ancestor, exit 0 each). Ticket counts and historical headings were not used as proof.src/shell/routes.tsat the base has 8 in-scope paths (/leitstand,/leitstand/verlauf,/betrieb,/einstellungen,/einstellungen/mcp,/einstellungen/benachrichtigungen,/einstellungen/projekt,/start); whether/leitstand/verlaufand any v2.1 route join the v2.0 list is Root's decision. Also open: scope of "exited eligibility", rows 13a–d and 17, and the meaning of the P0/P2 labels (taken from Root's order, not defined in the repo; the PLAN rows name concrete IDs instead). Technical criterion → command → exit table and the tab test per route are future work after Glass code.Evidence (command → exit)
bash scripts/sync.sh start→ 0;npm run dev:start-check -- --max-cargo 2 --min-free-gb 3.5→ 0 (13.5 GB free, 0 cargo builds; limit file/observe log not passed, reported as warning).gh pr list --state all --search 'KR-' --limit 1000 --json …→ 0 (25);gh pr list --state all --limit 3000 --json …→ 0 (1913);gh pr view 1915|1914|1916 --json …→ 0.node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0 ("0 Befunde", incl. no unknown-dependency, no duplicate ID, no cycle). Onlinenode scripts/plan-check.mjs --jsonbaseline before edits → 1 with 19 pre-existingstatus-contradicts-githubfindings (e.g. KR-08c-1, Z4-M4B-*, DOC-9); after edits 20, the only new one ispr-without-plan-rowfor the unrelated draft fix: keep live terminal chooser inside viewport and clear of tabs #1917; none caused by this change.bash scripts/ci/secret-scan.sh→ 0; pre-commit lane (crlf, eol, secrets, drift, plan-check, red-first withNo-Test) → commit exit 0; diff scanned for personal paths/addresses: none.bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushin this worktree → 0 (28 gates green; HEAD36e868eb).git push -u origin claude/v2-rest-plan-pflegen→ 0;git ls-remote origin claude/v2-rest-plan-pflegen→36e868eb9701bb1d407048ca4a1127bdce60957f, equal to local HEAD.NICHT ABGEDECKT
#[cfg(windows)]test is touched by a docs change; the Windows lane runs in the merge queue.git log --grep; rows 13a–d and 17 are UNKNOWN. Other agents' reports (Codex job for fix: keep live terminal chooser inside viewport and clear of tabs #1917, Root messages) are cited as such and were not re-verified beyond the exact PR reads above.Review
Review: ausstehend (Stufe C, gates only). Author is Anthropic; Root's own Anthropic review does not count as independent. Root dispatches reviews, head CI, acceptance, ready,
review-okand Mergify; this worker started none.Nachbesserung 26.10.2026 (Root order after the #1917 merge)
Heads / bases: old head
36e868eb9701bb1d407048ca4a1127bdce60957f; incoming mainbe8b70356ac888bfafdad6a7250a9155cdd77063(#1917 merged 2026-10-26T02:18:06Z, main CI success); new headeb9e380d141ac64e3996793043e3871befab451c(merge commit, parents36e868ebandbe8b7035).git merge-base HEAD origin/main=be8b7035.Conflict proof:
gh pr view 1918showedCONFLICTINGplus labelconflictafter the #1917 merge;git merge origin/mainreproduced a real content conflict indocs/PLAN.md(KR-08c-2b-LIVE vs. incoming FU-KR08C-LIVE-PLACEMENT row, the only hunk). Resolved by keeping both rows; no rebase, no force, no branch update button. After the pushgh pr viewshowsMERGEABLE.Corrections in
docs/PLAN.md(only these, no new row, no GI05 leaf row):be8b7035); RESTORE is the next candidate on a fresh base; exited-tab eligibility stays a separate unresolved residual and no prerequisite for RESTORE (R1918-Codex-P2). Chain 07a→11c→11d is conditional: KR-07a (ticket9df459e5-…) stays PARKED under Root 2026-10-24 23:42Z (default /beweise hidden/redirected by V2-SCOPE-1, visible entry is Elias' scope); no automatic unparking (R1918-Chief-P1). GI05 runs independently of RESTORE, the conservative cut does not make /beweise a visible default.fbbcf1db, 2026-10-25T16:58Z; primary source feat: launch profiles beside eligible live Glass terminal tabs #1915 (comment)). Other open items unchanged.be8b7035) and the bounded reviews and acceptance named in Root's comment on fix: keep live terminal chooser inside viewport and clear of tabs #1917 at head384eb4ed(Opus 5.5 and Sonnet 5.5 of Anthropic, Kimi k3 of Moonshot; fix: keep live terminal chooser inside viewport and clear of tabs #1917 (comment)). Native/installed/Glass/UAT/parent residuals kept.msg-0mvokawt4-326798eb, native 01:12:32.152Z) and the implementation child004c3d97-…(started 01:20:06Z, Claude Sonnet 5.5 per Root's dispatch; draft PR GLASS-GI05-HIDE: keep hidden Glass deep links with an honest notice #1919 observed open) are recorded as separate facts, not as delivered, tested, accepted or merged. GI02 stays open.Sizes: authored correction against the just-integrated tree: 6 PLAN rows/lines touched, about 11 raw added+deleted lines (<= 50). Final PR against fresh merge-base
be8b7035:docs/PLAN.md+19/−4 = 23 raw (<= 300). Full36e868eb..HEADdiff: 5 files, +248/−7, of which 4 files (+242/−2 runtime/test lines of #1917) are incoming main and not authored here; the P1-authored part is onlydocs/PLAN.md.Source-qualified findings (IDs repeat across sources, so the source is part of the ID):
review-pr1918-codex.md(head36e868eb)Commands (raw exit codes):
git merge origin/main→ 1 (real conflict, expected);node scripts/plan-check.mjs --offline→ 0 ("0 Befunde", no unresolved deps, no duplicate IDs);git commit(pre-commit lane incl. secret scan, red-first withNo-Test) → 0;bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepushin this worktree → 0 (also re-run by the push hook, push exit 0);git push -u origin claude/v2-rest-plan-pflegen→ 0;git ls-remote origin claude/v2-rest-plan-pflegen→eb9e380d141ac64e3996793043e3871befab451c= local HEAD. Old-head gates (36e868eb) are not reused as new-head evidence.Model: author
claude-sonnet-5-5(Claude subscription), requested effort high; the runtime exposes no effort field, so none is claimed. Admission at 02:33:57Z (file SHA-256bd798a62…26d877) was bound by the dispatcher.NICHT ABGEDECKT (addendum): Windows
#[cfg(windows)]tests and Windows clippy (merge queue). No product, native, installed/effective, Glass overall, UAT or release proof. Onlineplan-check --jsonwas not re-run (its pre-existing findings are untouched). The #1915/#1917 acceptance statements are quoted from the PR comments, not independently re-derived. The state of the GI05 child (#1919) is only "draft PR open" as observed at update time.Review: ausstehend (Stufe C, gates only; Root reads the delta; no further reviewer, no third round). Next owner: Root (ready,
review-okon the new head, Mergify queue).🤖 Generated with Claude Code
Root disposition of the remaining Chief finding (head
eb9e380d, 2026-10-26 03:20Z)docs/PLAN.md:279and:502still say GI05 is "nichts davon geliefert, getestet" although #1919 existsmain. As of this head GI05 is delivered only as draft PR #1919 (headdcc45032, author test and browser evidence in its report, Codex + Kimi K3.1 Pro reviews APPROVE, Root acceptance and merge still open). The status flips through #1919's own PLAN row at its merge; this PR does not pre-claim it. No extra reviewer or QA run.