event-storming(simulation): fresh-eyes tranche 2 — SCORE loop self-scoring, re-judge on next touch

[kyle-sexton]

Tranche-2 finding from the fresh-eyes checkpoint audit (program #304; wave-1 sweep 2026-07-19).

Finding: event-storming:simulation's SCORE loop numerically scores output the same context produced (self-grade class) — WEAK/MODERATE severity.

Why deferred: adequately mitigated today (iterative loop with human-visible intermediate output); deferral is a decision, not a gap (wave-2 Brief assumption).

Action on next touch: re-judge under the default-to-delegate rule once the delegation-mechanics doctrine + skill-quality check 18 land (wave-2 plan attached to #304). Outcome = conformant fresh-context delegation OR an explicit fresh-eyes-exempt directive with reason.

[kyle-sexton]

This was generated by AI during triage (historic normalization, rule 8g).

blocked by #304 decision — this is one of the tranche-2 per-plugin fresh-eyes retrofit instances #304 (the fresh-eyes checkpoint audit program) already anticipates as a Phase-2 candidate. Cluster-routed as a member of #304 rather than triaged separately; #304's own scope/sequencing decision (Phase 1 audit-first vs. per-plugin retrofit order) is what unblocks this issue.

[kyle-sexton]

Frontier disposition (drain session)

Ruling: Keep open — implementation still required (scoped).

Promoted to agent-ready for the drain session. Human gate cleared by frontier consensus.

[kyle-sexton]

Frontier disposition (drain session)

Ruling: Close as not planned.

Event-storming SCORE self-scoring is advisory simulation output; same fresh-eyes tranche-2 deferral as the other closed tranche-2 instances.

Re-open trigger: If SCORE-loop self-grading becomes autonomous acceptance evidence.