Skip to content

Quote Mark block styles on Paragraph and Heading blocks may be confusing #213

Closed

Description

@t-hamano

What happened?

#134 added the Text Statement pattern. Along with it, two block style variations that display ❝ on the Paragraph and Heading blocks, "Quote Mark" and "Quote Mark on Color", became available in the block inspector.

Strictly speaking, ❝ (U+275D) is a decorative symbol, but by convention it is used to visually indicate a quote or pullquote. As a result, users may apply this block style to a Paragraph block for content that should use a Quote or Pullquote block. In that case, the content looks like a quote, but the <blockquote> structure is lost. Because the markup does not express that the content is a quote, even assistive technologies that can announce and navigate quotes (such as JAWS and NVDA) will not treat it as one.

Proposal

  • Remove the two block style variations (styles/blocks/quote-mark.json and styles/blocks/quote-mark-on-color.json).
  • Replace the places in the patterns that use them (text-statement.php, text-statement-wide.php, and page-blog-home.php) with Quote blocks.

Where does it happen?

Somewhere else

Steps to reproduce

Insert a paragraph block or a heading block to open the block sidebar.

Screenshots or screen recording

Image

WordPress version

7.2 Beta4

PHP version

8.4

Ipsum version

1.0

Gutenberg plugin version

No response

Browser and device

No response

Before you submit

  • I searched the existing issues and this bug hasn't been reported yet.

Activity

  1. added
    [Type] BugAn existing feature does not function as intended
    on Nov 7, 2026
  2. juanfra commented on Nov 12, 2026

    @juanfra
    Member

    Thanks for reporting this one @t-hamano!

    @henriqueiamarino could you please take a look at this one? Would love to hear if these are crucial and worth keeping (and/or find ways to keep them somehow as styled patterns)

  3. henriqueiamarino commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @henriqueiamarino
    Contributor

    Hey @t-hamano and @juanfra, here’s where I land as the designer: the visual stays. The mark over a line is part of the theme’s voice, and I’m against removing it. The good news is the Quote block has carried this exact mark since the first beta, so routing the patterns through a Plain Quote keeps the look pixel-for-pixel while gaining the blockquote structure.

    On that condition, the patterns rendering the same, I don’t mind dropping the two Paragraph/Heading entries, which were duplicates of the Quote treatment born alongside the patterns in #134. So WordPress/ipsum#232 is the right direction. One ask there, seconding @MaggieCabrera: the on-color helper should be a registered Quote block style rather than a bare class, so it stays editable.

  4. t-hamano commented on Nov 15, 2026

    @t-hamano
    ContributorAuthor

    Thanks for the feedback!

    So #232 is the right direction.

    I partially agree, but the text in question, "I teach and write about books, slow mornings… start with the essays.", isn't a quotation in the first place. It reads like the site owner's own first-person introduction. Screen readers announce it as a quote, so from an accessibility and HTML spec point of view, this actually introduces confusion. The HTML spec defines blockquote as "a section that is quoted from another source".

    I'd suggest one of the following approaches:

    • If we keep it as a statement or introduction, it should stay a Paragraph block without the ❝ mark. If we really want to keep a mark, use a decoration that doesn't suggest a quotation.
    • If we rework it as a quotation, change the content to someone else's words.
  5. juanfra commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @juanfra
    Member

    Thanks @henriqueiamarino @t-hamano

    One thought on reworking it as a quotation, is that we're on the limit of string freeze from RC1. If we go that route, we'll need to get it merged today.

    cc @MaggieCabrera

  6. henriqueiamarino commented on Nov 16, 2026

    @henriqueiamarino
    Contributor

    Let’s rework it as a quotation then. Let's replace the first-person sentence in all three patterns by a line pulled from the demo persona’s own essays. We'd better use a citation, so the blockquote points to a real source. Proposed copy, one shared string as today:

    Quote: “Write the sentence first. The page can wait.”
    Cite: “From the essays”.

    As cite styling has been in theme.json since the first moment, this adds no CSS. @t-hamano does the cited pull-quote shape work for you?

  7. t-hamano commented on Nov 17, 2026

    @t-hamano
    ContributorAuthor

    Thanks for the update! As long as the copy isn't written in the first person, I don't have a strong opinion on it, so I'll leave that to those of you who are closely involved in the theme's development.

    As a side note, a citation isn't required for a quotation. If the citation affects the design, I think it's fine to remove it.

  8. added a commit that references this issue on Nov 17, 2026
    d26734e
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    [Type] BugAn existing feature does not function as intended

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions