You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Had you suggested it earlier, i may have concurred, but it's not just a question of changing a label name: I would have to change documentation in several places, change various tools, and socialise the change among current users. So, no, i'm not keen to do that.
fwiw, the original use of this label was for comments that had been created in the HR repo by a reviewer pending discussion by the i18n WG about whether or not to forward the comment to the spec WG. In that use, triaging wasn't really the point - rather the label indicated that the issue was hanging around pending a decision from the group. For the other uses of the pending label, we felt it would make life simpler not to create yet another label, since 'pending' was close enough.
If we were to change 'pending' to 'untriaged' it would require a significant amount of work and time to ripple that change out to all the necessary places, which i don't think would be justified by the gain.
Activity
plehegar commentedon May 7, 2020
@r12a , wdyt?
r12a commentedon May 12, 2020
Had you suggested it earlier, i may have concurred, but it's not just a question of changing a label name: I would have to change documentation in several places, change various tools, and socialise the change among current users. So, no, i'm not keen to do that.
plehegar commentedon May 14, 2020
closing for now. could be reopened later during a cross-horizontal discussion or so.
samuelweiler commentedon May 14, 2020
I'm going to reopen it now so we don't drop it. Also debating whether I feel strongly enough to ask us to special-case it.
r12a commentedon May 15, 2020
fwiw, the original use of this label was for comments that had been created in the HR repo by a reviewer pending discussion by the i18n WG about whether or not to forward the comment to the spec WG. In that use, triaging wasn't really the point - rather the label indicated that the issue was hanging around pending a decision from the group. For the other uses of the pending label, we felt it would make life simpler not to create yet another label, since 'pending' was close enough.
If we were to change 'pending' to 'untriaged' it would require a significant amount of work and time to ripple that change out to all the necessary places, which i don't think would be justified by the gain.