Skip to content

[Bug]: Completed permission notices overwhelm the conversation instead of starting collapsed #35918

Closed

Description

@gentslava

Operating system

macOS desktop; the same transcript presentation is used by Orca Mobile.

Orca version

Observed in local integration builds containing the conversation UI contributions. This report tracks the compact-notice behavior proposed in #33363; it is not a claim that every upstream release has the same rendering.

Details

Summary and impact

Completed automatic approval rejections and provider safety denials can occupy large red cards, repeatedly pushing conversation text off screen. Their diagnostic text is useful on demand, but it should not dominate normal reading.

Suggested severity: moderate / P2, subject to maintainer triage. This is a frequent readability and navigation disruption. No data loss or security bypass is reported. Active unanswered questions and approvals are a separate, actionable state and must keep working.

Reproduction

  1. Open a retained chat containing completed automatic-review or provider safety-denial records with long explanations.
  2. Read the conversation without expanding any diagnostics.
  3. Compare the amount of diagnostic text shown with the actual agent/user discussion.
  4. On mobile, switch the UI to Russian and expand a provider response that was capped by the host.

Actual: completed notices can show their full explanations immediately; newly compacted mobile headers may remain English, and expanded provider details can lose their truncation/original-size information.

Expected: show a short neutral summary by default. Expand the explanation and error color only on deliberate disclosure. Keep every available diagnostic reachable; clearly label a truncated provider response with its original size. Localized headers must follow live UI-language changes.

Acceptance boundaries

  • Successful routine tool activity may be grouped; completed rejections/denials remain distinct discoverable notices.
  • Pending questions and interactive approvals retain their actual response controls. This issue does not replace [Bug]: Active asynchronous questions show no answer controls #34357.
  • Expanded diagnostics preserve the host's bounded payload metadata and never claim a missing tail is complete output.
  • Desktop and mobile follow the same disclosure rule, including retained history and mixed-version hosts.

Proposed implementation and evidence

#33363 implements the compact presentation as one feature, separately from child-history inspection and asynchronous-question handling.

Historical matching before/after component captures are already attached in that PR. In the current review correction, six language-switch cases and two bounded-payload cases reproduced before the fix. After correction, 43 focused mobile tests and 230 desktop/shared tests pass. Existing tests check that details remain accessible and long diagnostic output scrolls within its bounded container.

These are controlled component/transport tests with synthetic records. Current-head installed-app, live-provider and physical-device acceptance are not claimed; broader checks are reported separately in the PR.

Related tracker: #33357.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions