Specify the Git-diff review confirmation Workflow Bundle #38

Activity

1. Sandstorm831

   added

   wayfinder:grillingHITL grilling decision ticketHITL grilling decision ticket

   on Aug 29, 2026
2. Sandstorm831

   added a parent issue on Aug 29, 2026

   • Chart Crucible's architecture and migration strategy #2
3. Sandstorm831

   marked this as blocked on Aug 29, 2026

   • Decide which Git operations Crucible performs for a Workflow and where they sit in the routing #14
4. Sandstorm831 commented on Aug 29, 2026

   

   Sandstorm831

   on Aug 29, 2026

   Last edited by Sandstorm831

   CollaboratorAuthor

   More actions

   Starting context

   Superseding inputs (2026-09-05): Read the Review checkpoint amendment and Bundle-contract amendment after the original linked resolutions. A Repeat group now requires a Bundle-authored review cadence/message, there is no launch-time interval or trust-revocation action, External Bundle uninstall removes its grant, and built-in Bundle removal remains undecided.

   Input	Why it matters	Authority
   Chart Crucible's architecture and migration strategy	Destination, planning scope, canonical terms, and standing constraints on routings, Bundles, and software-project workflows	Canonical map
   Decide which Git operations Crucible performs for a Workflow and where they sit in the routing	Governing decision: no Git Step kind or public Module; use ordinary Commands or Harness behaviour, declare git-worktree-root where required, and apply only generic trust and recovery	Canonical decision
   Choose Crucible's genericity-proof workflow	The original no-write confirmation-workflow candidate: diff two refs, produce findings, then let a Human Gate select a subset	Canonical starting concept
   Define the minimum generic Workflow capabilities	Uniform Step Interface, linear Routing, Command Verdict and output semantics, artifact types, prompt handoff, and the parked subset-selection gate; its provisional Git family is superseded by the Git decision above	Canonical decision with named supersession
   Define the self-contained Workflow Bundle contract and trust model	Strict manifest, structured PATH command invocation, platform overrides, script/schema assets, artifact validation, and trust summary; its fixed-precondition and Git-write details are superseded by the Git decision above	Canonical decision with named supersession

   Required methods

   • /grilling
   • /domain-modeling
   • /codebase-design

   Reading rule

   Read the Git decision first and do not design a Git-read Step kind, Git Module, special Git permission, or Git-specific recovery. Then read the confirmation-workflow candidate, followed by the generic Workflow and Bundle contracts. This ticket specifies one concrete Bundle—its inputs, Routing, portable Command, artifacts, schema, and gate—not new runtime semantics. Do not answer Harness capability semantics, persistence, or TUI presentation.
5. Sandstorm831

   added

   wayfinder:context-readyWayfinding ticket has curated starting context and may be claimedWayfinding ticket has curated starting context and may be claimed

   on Aug 29, 2026
6. Sandstorm831

   self-assigned this

   on Aug 29, 2026
7. Sandstorm831 commented on Sep 7, 2026

   

   Sandstorm831

   on Sep 7, 2026

   CollaboratorAuthor

   More actions

   Not required for v1

   This ticket is not a v1 prerequisite. The resolved sequencing decision, Sequence vertical slices, refactoring gates, and legacy deletion, keeps it open as a planning ticket outside the M0 to M6 sequence and schedules it after M6, with the Matt Bundle as the one v1 built-in. The handoff approval, Approve Crucible's architecture and migration handoff, confirmed it is not a prerequisite for M0 to M6.

   It stays open and context-ready for a later effort; nothing in v1 blocks on it.