Repository navigation
Added Report submission for Issue 43 - #146
Conversation
|
@reproducibility-org complete |
|
We made a modification to the final report submission. Thanks |
|
Hi, please find below a review submitted by one of the reviewers: Score: 9
Confidence : 5 |
|
Hi, please find below a review submitted by one of the reviewers: Score: 9 CODE COMMUNICATION WITH THE ORIGINAL AUTHORS HYPERPARAMETER SEARCH DISCUSSION ON RESULTS RECOMMENDATIONS FOR REPRODUCIBILITY I also appreciated that the authors of the report included a computational cost in their analysis, details that were missing in the original ICLR submission. DISCUSSION ON RESULTS As a minor issue, I do not understand why the plots on the first row in Figure 4 have a different style than the ones on the second and third row. I assume it is not relevant, but using the same style for plots would be required in the final submission. OVERALL ORGANIZATION AND CLARITY As minor issues: Confidence : 4 |
|
Hi, please find below a review submitted by one of the reviewers: Score: 9 Problem statement Code Communication with original authors Hyperparameter search Ablaton study Discussion on results Overall organization and clarity |
|
Meta Reviewer Decision: Accept |
#43