Skip to content

plugin-quality audit follow-ups: sweep-all internal tension, wait-what evals gap, orchestrate fork probe #2738

Description

@kyle-sexton

Small deferred items surfaced as blindspots/optional remediations by the 2026-08-15 plugin-quality audits applied in #2695 (audit packets under plugin-quality data, session a86db903, nonce 20260815T104849Z). None was applied there because each needs its own judgment or authoring pass rather than a mechanical edit:

  1. discipline/sweep-all internal tension (flagged, unaudited): its body says "The runbook never hardcodes member names" yet names scrutinize-dont-coast inline; and whether batch_promote can promote a never-tier corrector is unspecified between the userConfig text ("situational corrector skill names") and sweep-all's body. Reconcile the two (either the hardcode is a declared exception or it moves to tier metadata; state the never-tier promotion rule explicitly).
  2. discipline/wait-what ships no evals/ while the other 16 skills in the plugin do — consistency gap; author its eval suite.
  3. session-flow/orchestrate fork probe (auditor remediation 3 on the fork-claim finding): empirically probe whether a below-limit Agent-tool fork can spawn a non-fork subagent (the docs imply it via the depth-limit carve-out but never state it); record the outcome with a date in context/sources.md, per the skill's own confirm-from-behavior doctrine. feat(docs-hygiene): repo-wide sweep escalation for audit-derivability + apply the sweep's confirmed verdicts #2695 already narrowed the prose claim to what the docs state.
  4. discipline declared-delta conformance of the other 11 skills was not audited (the audit covered the five exercised correctors; do-your-research-deep visibly runs an extended loop with a "step 6"). A cheap conformance pass against the method doc's declared-delta rule would close the set.

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions