Summary
The dismiss_pull_request_review tool contract says review_id may be omitted for automatic actor-review selection, and the apply handler supports omission/auto, but safe-output ingestion requires review_id. Samples therefore cannot express the documented automatic-selection path.
Reproduction and observed behavior
A sample with:
replays through MCP, then ingestion rejects it:
dismiss_pull_request_review 'review_id' must be a valid positive integer (got: auto)
Removing review_id, as the tool description instructs, also replays successfully but ingestion rejects it:
dismiss_pull_request_review 'review_id' is required
The apply stage receives no messages and the prepared REQUEST_CHANGES review remains undismissed.
Expected: ingestion should accept omission (and, if intended by the public contract, auto) and pass the message to the apply handler's automatic review lookup.
Tested against github/gh-aw main commit eaca36f in source mode with --use-samples.
Parent: https://github.com/githubnext/gh-aw-test/actions/runs/32615153966
Child: https://github.com/githubnext/gh-aw-test/actions/runs/32616136031
Summary
The dismiss_pull_request_review tool contract says review_id may be omitted for automatic actor-review selection, and the apply handler supports omission/auto, but safe-output ingestion requires review_id. Samples therefore cannot express the documented automatic-selection path.
Reproduction and observed behavior
A sample with:
replays through MCP, then ingestion rejects it:
Removing review_id, as the tool description instructs, also replays successfully but ingestion rejects it:
The apply stage receives no messages and the prepared REQUEST_CHANGES review remains undismissed.
Expected: ingestion should accept omission (and, if intended by the public contract, auto) and pass the message to the apply handler's automatic review lookup.
Tested against github/gh-aw main commit eaca36f in source mode with --use-samples.
Parent: https://github.com/githubnext/gh-aw-test/actions/runs/32615153966
Child: https://github.com/githubnext/gh-aw-test/actions/runs/32616136031