Prompt Audit Findings
Medium
1. mention-in-pr-no-sandbox lost the merge-conflict handling branch present in mention-in-pr
Workflow(s): mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md, mention-in-pr.prompt.md
Evidence:
mention-in-pr.prompt.md:285 says combined requests are expected and ordered handling is required:
- "Requests can combine multiple actions ... handle them in this order: merge conflicts first, then code changes/review feedback, then push once at the end."
mention-in-pr.prompt.md:310-316 contains an explicit "If asked to fix merge conflicts:" section with concrete steps.
mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md:284 reduces this to "Based on what's asked, do the appropriate thing:" and has no merge-conflict section in the subsequent instruction branches (mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md:286-315).
Impact:
The no-sandbox PR assistant variant can receive the same mixed requests but lacks explicit merge-conflict handling guidance, which can lead to inconsistent behavior (e.g., skipping conflict-resolution flow or incorrect operation ordering compared to the sandboxed variant).
Suggested fix:
Mirror the merge-conflict handling block and combined-request ordering from mention-in-pr.prompt.md into mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md, preserving only intentional no-sandbox differences.
Summary
Audited 58 prompt files across workflow families (PR workflows, issue workflows, scheduled audits/detectors, fixers/improvers, and other utilities).
- Critical: 0 findings
- High: 0 findings
- Medium: 1 finding
What is this? | From workflow: Scheduled Audit
Give us feedback! React with 🚀 if perfect, 👍 if helpful, 👎 if not.
Prompt Audit Findings
Medium
1.
mention-in-pr-no-sandboxlost the merge-conflict handling branch present inmention-in-prWorkflow(s):
mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md,mention-in-pr.prompt.mdEvidence:
mention-in-pr.prompt.md:285says combined requests are expected and ordered handling is required:mention-in-pr.prompt.md:310-316contains an explicit "If asked to fix merge conflicts:" section with concrete steps.mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md:284reduces this to "Based on what's asked, do the appropriate thing:" and has no merge-conflict section in the subsequent instruction branches (mention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md:286-315).Impact:
The no-sandbox PR assistant variant can receive the same mixed requests but lacks explicit merge-conflict handling guidance, which can lead to inconsistent behavior (e.g., skipping conflict-resolution flow or incorrect operation ordering compared to the sandboxed variant).
Suggested fix:
Mirror the merge-conflict handling block and combined-request ordering from
mention-in-pr.prompt.mdintomention-in-pr-no-sandbox.prompt.md, preserving only intentional no-sandbox differences.Summary
Audited 58 prompt files across workflow families (PR workflows, issue workflows, scheduled audits/detectors, fixers/improvers, and other utilities).
What is this? | From workflow: Scheduled Audit
Give us feedback! React with 🚀 if perfect, 👍 if helpful, 👎 if not.