Skip to content

docs(epic): regenerate quickfiler-suite-determinism epic-status after final merge - #596

Merged
drmoisan merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
docs/epic-status-quickfiler-determinism-final
Aug 22, 2026
Merged

docs(epic): regenerate quickfiler-suite-determinism epic-status after final merge#596
drmoisan merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
docs/epic-status-quickfiler-determinism-final

Conversation

@drmoisan

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Suggested title

docs(epic): regenerate quickfiler-suite-determinism epic-status after final merge

Summary

  • Regenerates the checkpoint-derived sections of the generated status projection
    docs/features/epics/quickfiler-suite-determinism-foundation/epic-status.md now that the epic's
    final integration pull request has landed on main.
  • Records the final integration pull request and its CI gate in full: PR fix(quickfiler): suite-determinism foundation epic — remove live test form, repair keyboard-action and explorer-controller contract defects (#445, #449, #491) #595, merged as
    20462ed7fa4f4d9a23c02bc504f20b96b52f3060, gated by workflow run 32593830908 with 5 of 5 checks
    passing, with the run's headSha verified equal to the pull request's headRefOid before the
    gate was accepted.
  • Adds a Completion Assessment section that states plainly which of the four epic completion
    requirements are satisfied and which are not, and why.
  • Supersedes two kickoff-time notes that the actual outcome overtook, rather than deleting them, so
    a later reader can see what changed and why.
  • Records the outstanding worktree cleanup and the reason it could not be performed.
  • Documentation only. No production code, test code, build configuration, or workflow file is
    touched by this pull request.

Why

epic-status.md is a generated projection of artifacts/orchestration/epic-orchestrator-state.json,
regenerated by epic-orchestrator at kickoff, at every merge_status transition, at every wave
transition, and at final integration-pull-request completion. The last regeneration before this one
was taken at 2026-08-22T17-05, when the final pull request had not yet been opened. The document
therefore still described the run as in progress and still carried two instructions that the final
merge has since resolved. Regenerating it at the final boundary is the last of the four completion
requirements the epic orchestration procedure defines.

What Changed

Status header and wave table

  • Last updated advanced to 2026-08-22T18-05.
  • Next step advanced from open_final_integration_pr_to_main_closing_445_449_491 to
    EPIC_DELIVERED_WITH_ONE_CHILD_DESCOPED.
  • The integration branch is marked as merged to main; wave 0 moves from in_progress to
    completed_with_one_child_descoped.
  • The feature-status row for Bug: winformspumphost-tests-load-flaky-visible-window #511 now names its disposition inline (halted, premise_falsified,
    descoped) rather than showing a bare worktree_created that reads as unfinished work.

Final Integration Pull Request section

Previously a table of five em-dashes. Now records pr_number, pr_url, base_branch,
head_branch, head_sha, ci_gate, merge_commit_sha and merged_at, plus two new subsections:

  • CI gate detail — a per-check table, and the observation that this pull request received real
    GitHub Actions CI precisely because it targets main, which is in the pull_request trigger list
    of .github/workflows/ci.yml, unlike every child pull request in the epic. It also records that
    scripts/orchestration/Invoke-CiGateParser.ps1 does not exist in this repository, so the gate was
    evaluated directly from gh pr checks and gh run view, and is reported parser-absent rather
    than fabricated or silently skipped.
  • Issue disposition, verified after the merge — a table of all twelve issue states as read back
    with gh issue view after the merge: 445, 449 and 491 CLOSED; 511, 571, 583, 584, 586, 589, 592,
    593 and 594 OPEN.

Superseded notes

Two notes are marked superseded in place rather than removed:

  • The kickoff-time expectation that the final pull request must carry the closing keywords for all
    five of 445, 449, 491, 511 and 571. It carried closing keywords for the three children that
    actually landed. 511 and 571 were left open deliberately, because closing them would assert a fix
    that does not exist.
  • The instruction to re-check child Bug: quickfiler-test-form1-live-form #491's coverage AC10 against the integrated tree. Discharged:
    the mstest-coverage job passed on the integrated tree in run 32593830908.

The analyzer version-skew note is reframed from "live risk for the final PR" to "did not fire on the
final PR; still open". build-analyzers and build-nullable both passed, which the note itself
predicted would happen while the actions/cache fallback entry survives. The underlying defect is
unchanged and still open.

New Completion Assessment section

States the final position without softening it:

# Requirement Status
1 Every feature merged or worktree_removed NOT SATISFIED, by design — #511 descoped
2 Final integration pull request merged, merge_commit_sha recorded SATISFIED
3 epic-status.md reflects the completed state SATISFIED by this change
4 Checkpoint passes require_complete=True NOT SATISFIED, consequent on requirement 1

Requirements 1 and 4 fail together on the single descoped child and represent a deliberate
disposition, not an unfinished step. The section also records that all four child worktrees remain
framework-locked by the live session process, that removal was attempted three times and deferred
each time, and that forcing is prohibited.

Architecture / How It Fits Together

No runtime wiring is involved. epic.md remains the human-authored manifest and narrative source of
truth and is untouched. artifacts/orchestration/epic-orchestrator-state.json remains the durable,
machine-authoritative checkpoint; it is gitignored and is not part of this diff. epic-status.md is
the human-readable projection of that checkpoint, and is the only file this pull request modifies.

Verification

Completed:

Recommended:

  • Read the rendered Markdown tables on GitHub to confirm the new per-check and issue-disposition
    tables render correctly.

No toolchain gate applies to a Markdown-only change: the CSharpier check set excludes .md, and no
analyzer, nullable or MSTest stage reads this path.

Backward Compatibility / Migration Notes

None. No public API, contract, path or configuration changes. The document is a generated projection
with no consumers other than human readers.

Risks and Mitigations

  • Risk: the document could drift from the checkpoint it projects. Mitigation: every field
    written here was re-derived from GitHub and git at the time of writing, and the checkpoint was
    updated in the same operation.
  • Risk: a reader could mistake the superseded notes for current instructions. Mitigation:
    each is labelled superseded in place with the reason and the outcome that overtook it, rather than
    silently deleted.
  • Rollback: revert the single commit. Nothing depends on this file.

Review Guide

One file, one theme. Suggested order: the Completion Assessment section first (it states the
outcome), then the Final Integration Pull Request section (it carries the evidence), then the
superseded notes (they explain what changed relative to the previous generation).

Follow-ups

GitHub Auto-close

None. GitHub validation was unavailable in the context bundle and no autoclose issues were verified
or asserted. This pull request intentionally closes nothing: the three issues the epic delivered were
already closed by PR #595, and every remaining issue is genuinely unresolved.

… final merge

Regenerate the checkpoint-derived sections of the epic-status projection for
quickfiler-suite-determinism-foundation now that the final integration pull
request has landed.

- Record PR #595 (merged as 20462ed at 2026-08-22T22:03:11Z) with its full CI
  gate detail: workflow run 32593830908, 5 of 5 checks pass, headSha verified
  equal to the pull request headRefOid before the gate was accepted.
- Note that scripts/orchestration/Invoke-CiGateParser.ps1 does not exist in this
  repository, so the gate was evaluated directly from gh pr checks and gh run
  view, and is reported parser-absent rather than fabricated or skipped.
- Record the post-merge issue disposition verified with gh issue view: 445, 449
  and 491 CLOSED; 511, 571, 583, 584, 586, 589, 592, 593 and 594 OPEN.
- Supersede two kickoff-time notes that the outcome overtook: the expectation
  that the final pull request would close all five of 445/449/491/511/571, and
  the instruction to re-check child #491's coverage AC10 against the integrated
  tree (discharged by the mstest-coverage job on run 32593830908).
- Reframe the analyzer version skew note: it did not fire on this run because
  the actions/cache fallback entry is still alive. The defect remains open.
- Add a Completion Assessment section stating plainly that requirements 1 and 4
  are not satisfied, by design, on the single descoped child #511, and that the
  epic is reported as delivered-with-one-child-descoped rather than complete.
- Record the outstanding worktree cleanup: all four child worktrees remain
  framework-locked by the live session pid, removal was attempted three times
  and deferred, and forcing is prohibited.

Refs #511
Refs #571

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
@drmoisan
drmoisan merged commit d15f951 into main Aug 22, 2026
5 checks passed
@drmoisan
drmoisan deleted the docs/epic-status-quickfiler-determinism-final branch August 22, 2026 22:16
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant