Repository navigation
Closed
Description
PASS-8 R5-honest deep-sweep — Appendix F→M rename completion + image-gate
Follow-up to PASS-7 (#757, merged). PASS-8 ran a 10-dimension audit across the 5-repo Trinity hive after PASS-7 merges; this issue tracks the trios findings.
Anomalies discovered
| ID | Severity | Class | Files |
|---|---|---|---|
| A3 | 🔴 HIGH | Appendix rename incomplete | docs/phd/appendix/M-fpga-bitstream.tex — TOC entry, 13 section headers (F.0..F.11), 12 labels (sec:appF-*), and 25 internal \S F.x references all still carry the old F prefix despite the file being renamed M-fpga-bitstream.tex (App.F is now Coq Citation Map per main.tex:417). |
| A4 | 🔴 HIGH | Image-gate (silent-drop) + thematic mismatch | docs/phd/appendix/F-coq-citation-map.tex:15 — \includegraphics{app-f-bitstream-archive.png}. The Coq Citation Map appendix renders an FPGA-bitstream-archive figure that belongs in App.M, AND the PNG does not exist on main (only on feat/illustrations). |
| A5 | 🔴 HIGH | Image-gate (silent-drop) | docs/phd/appendix/M-fpga-bitstream.tex:9 — same missing PNG (the file app-f-bitstream-archive.png / app-m-bitstream-archive.png is not on main). |
| A6 | 🟡 MED | Filename drift | docs/phd/appendix-F-fpga-expansion-audit.md — file naming reflects pre-rename identity; the audit document tracks task 2.7 for the FPGA appendix, which is now App.M. |
Out-of-scope tracking (observation, no PASS-8 fix)
| ID | Severity | Class | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| A7 | 🟠 OBSERV | Image-gate wide miss | The full image-gate sweep across docs/phd/ finds 44 \includegraphics references in .tex files; none of the referenced filenames exist in either of the two graphicspath directories (docs/phd/assets/ is empty; trios/assets/illustrations/ carries 34 PNGs named 00-monad.png..33-epilogue.png, not ch01-introduction.png etc.). This is an architectural gap (the .tex references and the actual illustration filenames are in completely different naming schemes), tracked here as observation only — fix requires an operator-level decision on which naming scheme to canonicalise (rename PNGs vs rewrite 44 \includegraphics). |
R5-honest audit probes
- ✅ Community
trinity-s3ailive-verified: 12 records, no drift - ✅ All 12 canonical DOIs return HTTP 200
- ✅ Bibliography
.biband Coq.vDOI citations: no drift since PASS-7 - ✅ Cargo / package manifests: no DOI drift
- ✅ GitHub Actions workflows: no DOI drift
- ✅ Cross-repo ORCID drift: zero (post-PASS-7 t27 fix holds)
- 🔴 Appendix-F-or-M consistency probe → A3/A4/A5/A6 surfaced
- 🟠 Full
\includegraphicsimage-gate probe → A7 observation
Fix plan (companion PR)
- A3: surgical sed-rename inside
M-fpga-bitstream.texonly: TOC entry, 13 section headersF.x→M.x, 12 labelssec:appF-*→sec:appM-*, 25 internal\S F.x→\S M.xreferences. External cross-references verified empty (no other.texfile references the renamed labels), so the rename is local and safe. - A4: remove broken
\includegraphicsblock fromF-coq-citation-map.tex:15with R5-honest audit comment +TODO(LD)for a thematically-correct Coq corpus statistics blueprint figure. - A5: remove broken
\includegraphicsblock fromM-fpga-bitstream.texwith R5-honest audit comment +TODO(LD)for a proper bitstream-archive figure. - A6:
git mvappendix-F-fpga-expansion-audit.md→appendix-M-fpga-expansion-audit.mdwith banner explaining the rename; update cross-references inappendix-G-expansion-audit.mdandAUDIT_REPORT.md. - A7: leave in place; capture in this issue as a future operator decision.
Cross-refs
- Throne: 👑 TRINITY HIVE — Queen's Registry & ONE SHOT Dispatch #264
- PASS-7 predecessor: chore(zenodo): PASS-7 R5-honest — RAG chunks, App.H→App.N, image-gate #757 (merged)
- App.N introduction: feat(phd): Appendix F §F.7 cross-repo audit (678 theorems) + F+F/H+H collision fix #743
- Companion PASS-8 PR in
t27: chore(zenodo): PASS-8 fix placeholder DOIs in t27 .bib files t27#601 (placeholder DOIs in .bib files) - Single source of truth: https://zenodo.org/communities/trinity-s3ai/
φ² + φ⁻² = 3 · TRINITY · R5-HONEST · PASS-8
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity
chore(zenodo): PASS-9 — image-gate root-fix + broken refs
gHashTag commentedon May 19, 2026
Requires external repo (trios-trainer-igla / trios-railway / t27 / trinity-fpga) or operator access. Not actionable in this repo.