Skip to content

PASS-8 R5-honest deep-sweep — Appendix F→M rename completion + image-gate #762

Closed

Description

@gHashTag

PASS-8 R5-honest deep-sweep — Appendix F→M rename completion + image-gate

Follow-up to PASS-7 (#757, merged). PASS-8 ran a 10-dimension audit across the 5-repo Trinity hive after PASS-7 merges; this issue tracks the trios findings.

Anomalies discovered

ID Severity Class Files
A3 🔴 HIGH Appendix rename incomplete docs/phd/appendix/M-fpga-bitstream.tex — TOC entry, 13 section headers (F.0..F.11), 12 labels (sec:appF-*), and 25 internal \S F.x references all still carry the old F prefix despite the file being renamed M-fpga-bitstream.tex (App.F is now Coq Citation Map per main.tex:417).
A4 🔴 HIGH Image-gate (silent-drop) + thematic mismatch docs/phd/appendix/F-coq-citation-map.tex:15 — \includegraphics{app-f-bitstream-archive.png}. The Coq Citation Map appendix renders an FPGA-bitstream-archive figure that belongs in App.M, AND the PNG does not exist on main (only on feat/illustrations).
A5 🔴 HIGH Image-gate (silent-drop) docs/phd/appendix/M-fpga-bitstream.tex:9 — same missing PNG (the file app-f-bitstream-archive.png / app-m-bitstream-archive.png is not on main).
A6 🟡 MED Filename drift docs/phd/appendix-F-fpga-expansion-audit.md — file naming reflects pre-rename identity; the audit document tracks task 2.7 for the FPGA appendix, which is now App.M.

Out-of-scope tracking (observation, no PASS-8 fix)

ID Severity Class Note
A7 🟠 OBSERV Image-gate wide miss The full image-gate sweep across docs/phd/ finds 44 \includegraphics references in .tex files; none of the referenced filenames exist in either of the two graphicspath directories (docs/phd/assets/ is empty; trios/assets/illustrations/ carries 34 PNGs named 00-monad.png..33-epilogue.png, not ch01-introduction.png etc.). This is an architectural gap (the .tex references and the actual illustration filenames are in completely different naming schemes), tracked here as observation only — fix requires an operator-level decision on which naming scheme to canonicalise (rename PNGs vs rewrite 44 \includegraphics).

R5-honest audit probes

  • ✅ Community trinity-s3ai live-verified: 12 records, no drift
  • ✅ All 12 canonical DOIs return HTTP 200
  • ✅ Bibliography .bib and Coq .v DOI citations: no drift since PASS-7
  • ✅ Cargo / package manifests: no DOI drift
  • ✅ GitHub Actions workflows: no DOI drift
  • ✅ Cross-repo ORCID drift: zero (post-PASS-7 t27 fix holds)
  • 🔴 Appendix-F-or-M consistency probe → A3/A4/A5/A6 surfaced
  • 🟠 Full \includegraphics image-gate probe → A7 observation

Fix plan (companion PR)

  1. A3: surgical sed-rename inside M-fpga-bitstream.tex only: TOC entry, 13 section headers F.x→M.x, 12 labels sec:appF-*→sec:appM-*, 25 internal \S F.x→\S M.x references. External cross-references verified empty (no other .tex file references the renamed labels), so the rename is local and safe.
  2. A4: remove broken \includegraphics block from F-coq-citation-map.tex:15 with R5-honest audit comment + TODO(LD) for a thematically-correct Coq corpus statistics blueprint figure.
  3. A5: remove broken \includegraphics block from M-fpga-bitstream.tex with R5-honest audit comment + TODO(LD) for a proper bitstream-archive figure.
  4. A6: git mv appendix-F-fpga-expansion-audit.md → appendix-M-fpga-expansion-audit.md with banner explaining the rename; update cross-references in appendix-G-expansion-audit.md and AUDIT_REPORT.md.
  5. A7: leave in place; capture in this issue as a future operator decision.

Cross-refs

φ² + φ⁻² = 3 · TRINITY · R5-HONEST · PASS-8

Activity

  1. gHashTag commented on May 19, 2026

    @gHashTag
    CollaboratorAuthor

    Requires external repo (trios-trainer-igla / trios-railway / t27 / trinity-fpga) or operator access. Not actionable in this repo.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions