Repository navigation
ST-C01: 5-digit face/join code silently disables Join with no readable reason #1052
Description
Reproduce
Two fresh FlyBot homes on main b9a66e1 (SelfA1025 :3090 / SelfB1025 :3091 → https://47-80-69-220.sslip.io):
- On A, open the sidebar + menu → Join or create by number or link.
- Dialog title and body mention a 6-digit number; input placeholder reads "6 digits".
- Type exactly 5 digits (e.g.
58291). Do not add a 6th.
Expected
A readable refusal while Join stays disabled — e.g. helper text "Enter 6 digits" (or equivalent) under the field — so the user knows why the primary action is blocked.
Actual
Join stays greyed out / disabled with no helper text, no error, no hint. The dialog looks idle; the only cue is the disabled button.
Environment
- SHA:
b9a66e1e87133b3771ee63f01204c3546fee5490 - Homes: SelfA1025 (
@selfa1025.home:3090), SelfB1025 (@selfb1025.home:3091) - Social:
https://47-80-69-220.sslip.io - Catalog: ST-C01 (face-to-face entry — 5-digit code refused with a readable reason)
Screenshots (on box; not uploaded)
/workspace/social-ui-deep-test/shots/09-A-5digit.png— dialog open, field shows58291, Join disabled, no validation message under the input. (Background may show unrelatedMISSING_CREDENTIALfrom the test home model setup — out of scope for this issue.)
Suggested scope
- Client validation on the face/join digit field: when length is 1–5 (or otherwise invalid), keep Join disabled and show a short helper under the field ("Enter 6 digits").
- Empty field can stay silent; the gap is partial entry with no explanation.
- Mirror in CN copy if EN lands first.
- Acceptance: enter 5 digits → helper visible; enter 6th digit → helper clears and Join enables; paste a valid invite URL still uses the link path.
Source
product UI deep-test 2026-10-25
Activity
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Claimed by Birfy. Branch:
birfy/fix/1052-face-5digit-helper, from mainb9a66e1e87133b3771ee63f01204c3546fee5490.Plan: add client-side helper under the face/join digit field when length is 1–5 ("Enter 6 digits"); clear helper and enable Join at 6 digits; leave empty field silent; keep link-paste path unchanged. Red UI/unit check for 5-digit → helper visible.
Written-by: Birfy
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Closing for now per owner: findings not yet re-verified against
social.botawaken.com. Will reopen only if confirmed on a fresh UI pass.Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Closing at owner's request pending re-verification on social.botawaken.com — these findings may be false positives and are not yet confirmed.
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Confirmed on reverify2 (2026-10-25, social.botawaken.com): entering 5 digits leaves Join disabled with only the "6 digits" placeholder and no readable reason. Reopening; claimed by Birfy.
Birfy commentedon Oct 25, 2026
Written-by: Triage
agent-workingremoved — nothing is being worked on this one (no owner branch, no PR), so it was reading as in-flight on the board while it was not.The repro is on main
b9a66e1, which is now four merges behindc062fb02. Please re-run the same steps on current main before this goes to a Dev: a defect that only exists on a stale build costs a whole PR round.Labels stay as they are if the re-run reproduces. If it does not, close it or move it to
needs-infowith what changed.Offer to start a room when nobody is waiting