You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
A verified public-path blocker for #1218's mixed exploratory/qualified-route regression and #1213's permanent publishing-path assessment under #1194.
At main cddc04c, public resumable construction publishes a CAS graph/files participant. Calling GraphForge::adopt_ontology with an Advisory ontology then fails with PublicationFailed: graph/files v2 root must reference project objects, not a generation graph tree. Reproduced in the #1218 integration fixture before any typed-child construction or delta replay. workspace_ontology::publish_workspace_records_inner treats any graph/files participant as generation-tree ownership and selects parent.graph_tree_root(), despite preserving the CAS participant. Compact publication also requires a graph-object lease through CURRENT.
Searches for ontology/CAS and workspace publication/graph tree found no duplicate. #1219 repaired delta/compaction ownership; this is a distinct workspace publication caller. Two changes remain unmerged (#1218 and #1213), so this bounded blocker fits the three-change WIP limit.
Acceptance:
Given a graph published by public construction, Advisory ontology adoption with disjoint new type names (no retained-label promotion) and the existing workspace-record publication path preserve its declared graph ownership, authenticated graph inventory and payload identities. Select a generation tree only for a generation-owned participant; retain the CAS publication lease through CURRENT for CAS participants.
Preserve complete participant/capability state, semantic metadata, idempotency, parent-conflict checks and cancellation. Explicit candidate graph-tree transforms retain their own declared ownership. Do not copy/re-encode every graph payload to work around the mismatch.
Focused PR with deterministic ownership and resource evidence, relevant tests, exact-head required CI Gate, independent review and squash merge.
No Parquet policy/default change, compatibility/migration machinery, generic writer abstraction, or unrelated maintenance-facade refresh work. Native sub-issue of #1194, blocking #1194, #1218 and #1213. Existing issue bodies remain the canonical close gates.
Verified scope boundary: same-name ontology promotion rewrites graph authorities and is not an ownership-only workspace record change. A local public construction → adopt matching Node0 ontology reproduces a retained UUID manifest link-ownership failure; an experimental local control/run ownership change then exposes stale v4 ordinal authentication because adoption publishes workspace records before rewriting private graph authorities. Preserve this reproducer under #1221, which owns atomic complete graph/ordinal publication and reader refresh. #1222 must not claim to repair same-name promotion or weaken UUID guards.
The same ownership assumption also occurs in composition preflight: runtime_symbols reads current.graph_tree_root()/topology/runtime_catalog.parquet, returning an empty catalog for CAS and falsely reporting runtime_catalog_generation_drift even after reopen. Include authenticated manifest-selected CAS catalog loading (bounded to that catalog, not graph materialization) and preserve the genuine live-catalog drift rejection. Public composition preview/publication establishes the semantic bindings needed for qualified construction; simple adoption alone does not.
A verified public-path blocker for #1218's mixed exploratory/qualified-route regression and #1213's permanent publishing-path assessment under #1194.
At main cddc04c, public resumable construction publishes a CAS graph/files participant. Calling
GraphForge::adopt_ontologywith an Advisory ontology then fails withPublicationFailed: graph/files v2 root must reference project objects, not a generation graph tree. Reproduced in the #1218 integration fixture before any typed-child construction or delta replay.workspace_ontology::publish_workspace_records_innertreats any graph/files participant as generation-tree ownership and selectsparent.graph_tree_root(), despite preserving the CAS participant. Compact publication also requires a graph-object lease through CURRENT.Searches for ontology/CAS and workspace publication/graph tree found no duplicate. #1219 repaired delta/compaction ownership; this is a distinct workspace publication caller. Two changes remain unmerged (#1218 and #1213), so this bounded blocker fits the three-change WIP limit.
Acceptance:
No Parquet policy/default change, compatibility/migration machinery, generic writer abstraction, or unrelated maintenance-facade refresh work. Native sub-issue of #1194, blocking #1194, #1218 and #1213. Existing issue bodies remain the canonical close gates.
Verified scope boundary: same-name ontology promotion rewrites graph authorities and is not an ownership-only workspace record change. A local public construction → adopt matching Node0 ontology reproduces a retained UUID manifest link-ownership failure; an experimental local control/run ownership change then exposes stale v4 ordinal authentication because adoption publishes workspace records before rewriting private graph authorities. Preserve this reproducer under #1221, which owns atomic complete graph/ordinal publication and reader refresh. #1222 must not claim to repair same-name promotion or weaken UUID guards.
The same ownership assumption also occurs in composition preflight:
runtime_symbolsreadscurrent.graph_tree_root()/topology/runtime_catalog.parquet, returning an empty catalog for CAS and falsely reportingruntime_catalog_generation_drifteven after reopen. Include authenticated manifest-selected CAS catalog loading (bounded to that catalog, not graph materialization) and preserve the genuine live-catalog drift rejection. Public composition preview/publication establishes the semantic bindings needed for qualified construction; simple adoption alone does not.