[Cuarroc]

Die Korrektur ist an der festen Zeilengrenze und der Prüfung auf unbenutzten Code blockiert.
Der gesicherte Entwurf hat private Felder und lesende Getter; der bestehende Vertragstest besteht weiterhin.
PR #2043 bleibt unverändert im Draft, bis Root den gemeldeten Konflikt entschieden hat.

Report

Plan-ID: V36-P01. CURRENT: BLOCKED / preserved uncommitted review-fix candidate. DRAFT only. Observation: 2026-10-30 00:54 UTC. No new commit or push; no current green prepush or review closure is claimed.

Fixed heads, authority and scope

Root msg-0mvu8xxau-1d2af07c authorizes the same owner/branch/package for R2043-F1 and optional R2043-F3 only. Original PR base: 688840893f3ece9962963afe2538b941db6e19bf. Reviewed head, current committed HEAD and verified remote remain 1dfee266c4b51d916835c2bdfb8c4c52a319b10f; the committed reviewed-head..new-head delta is empty. Observed main is 227e10dbdc454eabd2032edfc50812b6dc3a5a8f; no merge, rebase, reset or history rewrite occurred.

The only working-tree edit is src-tauri/src/project_shell/model.rs: delta 26 additions + 19 deletions against the reviewed head. main.rs and project_shell/mod.rs remain byte-identical to that head; every other repository file remains untouched. The candidate source and exact patch are preserved privately with a STOP receipt. Candidate model SHA-256: 4a87fc891cb08ec615b7b81b389d237de3cc989a6056bab6ba346d832fa91de3.

Blocking evidence and exact budget

The formatted candidate makes layout, safety and schema_version private, adds immutable-reference getters for layout/safety and a value getter for schema version, and adapts the original literal assertions to those public getters. It removes only the three explicitly authorized tautological FileZone comparisons and the now-unused test import. No genuine original oracle, comment, enum or constructor behavior was removed or weakened.

• Actual total against the original base: 249 RAW = 2 MAIN + 2 mod.rs + 245 model.rs, within HARD250.
• Actual canonical Clippy gate command fails: src-tauri/src/project_shell/model.rs:37, enum FileZone is never used, -D dead-code implied by -D warnings, exit 101.
• A standard rustfmt-stdin projection retaining the three original comparisons and their import measures 254 RAW = 2 + 2 + 250, exceeding HARD250 by four. This is a measured projection, not a second repository edit or a claim of green Clippy.
• Forcing IDs: R2043-F1 + R2043-F3. No new allow/expect, ratchet/baseline/gate change, consumer, extra file, minification or cap increase is authorized. The source work stopped at this evidenced conflict, as the brief requires. Root/Stabs own the next disposition; the worker inferred no cap lift or alternate scope.

Public boundary and compiler proof

Before the edit, a consumer outside the real model module compiled while assigning schema version 99, empty separated roots and replacement safety data after ProjectShell::new. The identical consumer against the candidate fails with E0616 for all three fields (four diagnostics including its schema read). This is a precise compiler privacy proof using the actual source, not a substitute for compiling the registered production module.

The real projecta binary test target compiled, listed exactly one selected test, and ran that same test successfully through the getters. SELECTOR is project_shell::model::tests::keeps_existing_product_repo_and_legacy_state_distinct.

Visibility enforcement cannot be expressed as a compiling behavioral assertion that attempts forbidden field access. An eventual commit would need the honest No-Test reason for this static privacy change; no new assertion-RED or trailer was fabricated. The original compiled count-one assertion RED at b55c646a46dd34f64df9eecb2882bfb58628d204 and its literal oracles remain historical evidence for the original behavior, not independent proof of R2043-F1.

Current evidence: commands and raw exits

Every heavy command used the unchanged foreground guard and phase in the same shell, target slot 3 and jobs 1. Guard SHA-256: a486bd256d4e58c4124e1147e3a57efe10a48a2a66ce08a6cccc80db4f11a59f; all admissions passed, no refusal was retried. Every command completed before the next command. No background command, agent, review, service or installation was started.

Command / observation	Raw exit	Result
bash scripts/sync.sh start	0	Same clean branch before edits
npm run dev:start-check	0	13.6 GB available, zero Cargo builds; provider/observation warnings retained
git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/codex/ms0-v36-p01	0	Exact current main and reviewed P01 head
gh pr view 2043 --json url,isDraft,headRefOid,headRefName,baseRefName	0	Same DRAFT and exact reviewed head
npm run hq:lesson -- search "Rust dead_code unused enum public inactive module"	0	Existing lessons consulted
rustc --edition 2021 --crate-name field_consumer --emit metadata ... against old real model	0	Invalid post-construction assignments compile; warnings are retained
Identical compiler consumer against candidate	1	E0616 for schema_version, layout and safety
rustfmt --edition 2021 src-tauri/src/project_shell/model.rs	0	Standard formatting, no golf
cargo test --manifest-path src-tauri/Cargo.toml --bin projecta SELECTOR -- --list	0	Exactly 1 selected test; FileZone warning
Same command with -- --exact	0	1 passed, 0 failed; FileZone warning
cargo clippy --manifest-path src-tauri/Cargo.toml --all-targets -- -D warnings	101	Actual gate failure: unused FileZone enum
git diff --check / candidate and unchanged-registration checks / rustfmt projection	0	Only model.rs changed; actual249/projected254 RAW

Native session header observed codex_exec, OpenAI, CLI 0.164.0, thread 01a18a49-3665-7693-bec3-9c17882d6069, start 00:50:16.307Z. Actual turn_context reports gpt-6.1-sol, effort high, turn 01a18a49-3774-78b1-a25d-6abe10183a02. Native rate-limit event at 00:54:11.402Z reports 40% used / 60% remaining in the 10080-minute window; this is dated harness evidence, not every-provider availability. The supplied quota snapshot was read separately. get_goal({}) returned goal:null, remainingTokens:null, completionBudgetReport:null at start and after STOP. No goal, budget, config or parent state changed.

Architecture drift

No new allowed occurrence, attribute, ceiling, baseline or config. The original inactive registration is untouched. R2043-F4's cfg_attr ratchet blind spot remains a separate follow-up; it was not implemented here.

NICHT ABGEDECKT

• This candidate has no successful full prepush. Full canonical red-first, precommit/secret scan, commit, full bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush, push hooks and new remote receipt were not run after the explicit budget/dead-code STOP. Previous successful gates below apply only to the original reviewed commit. No new head exists for independent review.
• Linux does not compile/run #[cfg(windows)] tests (run_in_pty, npm_shim, ConPTY, DPAPI) or Windows Clippy arms. The Windows lane runs in the merge queue. The original seven Rust skips and Denkraum Windows 8.3 skip remain uncovered and unchanged.
• No complete application Browser-Smoke, frontend build, full Linux workflow, external updater, OmniRoute or mirror-state claim. The start-check warnings are not quota/observation approval. The lage-jetzt mirror and memory tools are unavailable; live Git/PR evidence and the explicit bounded admission were used.
• R2043-F2: Separated names caller-supplied roots; it proves no containment. String validation establishes no filesystem identity, canonical roots or authority. Future P02/P03 owners retain implementation duties.
• All P00 future duties remain: forbidden-zone refusal before effects per admitted harness/App/Shell/CLI/MCP and children; unborn first checkout; allowed parent, canonical roots, alias/case/UNC/link/TOCTOU and common Git administration identity; helper destinations and preservation of existing product AGENTS/CLAUDE; backup integrity and conflict-safe restore; independent product copy; passive viewer read permission.
• No PF/security/forbidden-zone/product/native/effective/user/parent acceptance, creation, relocation, activation, grant, key or right. P02/P03/P06/P08/P16 dependencies remain binding.
• Independent reviews, Root acceptance, canonical CI success before queue, Windows evidence and merge remain pending. PLAN remains Stabs-owned and unchanged.

Finding disposition and next owner

Review: ausstehend (Stufe A).

Finding	Disposition
R2043-F1 medium	Accepted for implementation, preserved in uncommitted candidate; compiler privacy proof and public-getter test observed. Not closed: no committed/pushed green fix.
R2043-F3 optional	Attempted exactly as authorized; removing only the three tautological comparisons exposes the actual dead-code error. Blocked jointly with F1 under HARD250; no acceptance claimed.
R2043-F2 advisory	Explicit uncovered filesystem/containment limitation retained; future P02/P03 work, no implementation here.
R2043-F4 follow-up	Separate C package for cfg_attr allow-ratchet regex; out of scope.
R2043-F5 advisory	Future monolithic-test split; out of scope.

Root/Stabs decide the exact budget/dead-code conflict before any resumed author work. Root retains the commissioned Kimi/Moonshot new-head review and Fable/Anthropic delta round, maximum two rounds, as well as acceptance, Ready, review-ok and Mergify. No review was launched by the worker. Closing state: DRAFT / BLOCKED; committed head unchanged; one preserved model.rs WIP.

Historical checked delivery — original reviewed head only

The following is the preserved original delivery report. Its green checks and resolved earlier resource STOP are historical; neither describes the current uncommitted fix or supersedes the current STOP above.

Original checked DRAFT2043 delivery at 1dfee26 (historical)

Das inaktive Schema trennt Produkt, Hülle und Steuerung und erhält die bestehende Projektkennung sowie den Produktpfad.
Der Vertragstest wurde zuerst mit einem echten Assertion-Fehler und anschließend unverändert erfolgreich ausgeführt; die vollständigen lokalen Prüfungen sind grün.
Die unabhängigen Reviews und die Windows-Prüfung stehen noch aus; daraus folgt keine Freigabe für Produktanlage oder Schutzfunktionen.

Report

Plan-ID: V36-P01. DRAFT handover for independent review; no Ready, review-ok, queue, merge or parent acceptance by the author.

Scope and authority

Resumed the same preserved package under Root msg-0mvu79itb-df582c49 and the exclusive MAIN registration window msg-0mvu6n4i2-6b786110. The resource STOP was superseded only by this bounded admission; no scope, cap or guard change.

• Base: 688840893f3ece9962963afe2538b941db6e19bf.
• Red checkpoint: b55c646a46dd34f64df9eecb2882bfb58628d204.
• Candidate and verified remote: 1dfee266c4b51d916835c2bdfb8c4c52a319b10f, branch codex/ms0-v36-p01.
• Actual native turn_context, 2026-10-30T00:11:02.994Z: gpt-6.1-sol, effort high, OpenAI author. Both commits retain the exact Test-First selector and actual-model Co-Authored-By trailer.
• get_goal({}) returned goal:null, remainingTokens:null, completionBudgetReport:null at start and after verified push. No native goal, budget, configuration or parent completion was changed.
• P00 report SHA-256 independently matches 952046c9744265460129e43db07b8c25c99e816f3b23b7262d36f56bdbb99d9d. Factual acceptance is Root msg-0mvu5vc9h-81346bd5 / relay msg-0mvu62qod-95438ba5; P00 has no fictitious source merge. K00 input is merge 236f74be00bf0e3344a089f0b6a1efdb2affe54b.

Only src-tauri/src/project_shell/mod.rs, model.rs and the two-line inactive registration in src-tauri/src/main.rs change. RAW added+deleted against the merge-base is 242 <= 250 (2 + 2 + 238). MAIN is 4002 <= 4059 lines. No PLAN, Store, workers, API, CLI, Cargo or protected package changes. Stabs owns the later canonical PLAN status update.

Behavior and test boundary

The real production module declaration compiles the schema through the projecta binary. ProjectShell::new preserves the existing project ID and product repo_path verbatim. Layout explicitly distinguishes Legacy, Separated and Unknown; legacy/unknown inputs invent no wrapper or control root. Separated input names wrapper and control roles separately from the product repository. Schema version 1 is explicit; unsupported versions, malformed/empty required identity, malformed product paths and invalid literal separated roots are refused.

Safety origin and root identity are Unknown or explicitly Unverified metadata. Editable labels and checksums confer no authority. FileZone variants remain distinct and do not implement action risk, authorization, execution place or delivery acceptance. There is no serialization, persistence, migration, filesystem operation, runtime caller, product creation or rights effect.

The public-interface test uses literal expectations for two independent projects, legacy and unknown state, separated produkt/.projecta roles, metadata provenance, unsupported schema and malformed inputs. It tests the real constructor and public output, without an owned-module mock, private side channel or computed oracle.

Exact selector (abbreviated below as SELECTOR):
project_shell::model::tests::keeps_existing_product_repo_and_legacy_state_distinct.

The preserved 239-RAW source was freshly compiled: --list returned exactly 1 test, then --exact ran 1 and failed at the empty-identity assertion (Ok versus literal malformed-identity Err). This is the behavioral RED, distinct from the new test file's absence at the merge-base. The normal checkpoint hook first rejected formatting of the test import; only formatting changed before the successful 241-RAW checkpoint. The minimal empty-identity check then produced 242 RAW and the same test passed, without assertion changes.

Architecture drift

No new occurrences and no allowlist or ceiling changes. The inactive declaration uses the existing narrow cfg_attr(not(test), allow(dead_code)) pattern; test builds still check dead code. The ratchet remains rust-allow: 221 = 221.

Evidence: commands and raw exits

Observed on 2026-10-30 UTC in the assigned own worktree. Every shell exported the assigned warm target and CARGO_BUILD_JOBS=1; every heavy phase used the original guard and phase in the same foreground shell. Guard SHA-256 remained a486bd256d4e58c4124e1147e3a57efe10a48a2a66ce08a6cccc80db4f11a59f. Every admission passed in this continuation; no denied phase was retried. All commands were awaited; no background work, new agents, reviewers, services, installs or cache manipulation.

Command	Exit	Observed result
bash scripts/sync.sh start	0	Own branch and preserved three-file WIP
npm run dev:start-check	0	13.5 GB free, 0 Cargo builds; provider-limit/observe-log warnings retained
git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main refs/heads/codex/ms0-v36-p01	0	Initial main exact base; P01 remote absent
gh pr list --state open --limit 30 --json ...	0	Below WIP limit; protected drafts untouched
Guard/P00/source sha256sum and diff/line checks	0	Expected hashes; exact source scope and budgets
cargo test --manifest-path src-tauri/Cargo.toml --bin projecta SELECTOR -- --list	0	Real compiling RED snapshot, exactly 1 test
Same selector with -- --exact, before fix	101	1 assertion failure, empty project ID accepted
First normal checkpoint git commit -F <message>	1	fmt rejected import wrapping; no commit created
npm run hq:lesson -- search "cargo fmt Rust import formatting"	0	Existing lessons consulted before correction
Normal red checkpoint git commit -F <message>	0	Full precommit, staged secret scan and trailer hook passed
Same exact cargo selector after fix	0	1 passed, 0 failed
cargo test --manifest-path src-tauri/Cargo.toml --bin projecta core_register::tests::	0	12 passed
cargo test --manifest-path src-tauri/Cargo.toml --bin projecta projects_round_trip	0	1 existing isolated-fixture project test passed
Normal fix git commit -F <message>	0	Full precommit, staged secret scan and trailer hook passed
bash scripts/ci/red-first.sh	0	Full canonical check, unchanged isolated targets; absent at base, positive count1 GREEN at head for both identical trailer references
bash scripts/ci/gates.sh lane prepush	0	Own candidate; all 28 gates green, 2332 Rust tests passed, 7 skipped; 240 seconds
git ls-remote origin refs/heads/main and clean-tree assertion before push	0	Admitted base unchanged; candidate clean
git push -u origin codex/ms0-v36-p01	0	Foreground push; normal full prepush hook also green (194 seconds), 2332 passed, 7 skipped
git ls-remote origin codex/ms0-v36-p01 plus exact-SHA assertion	0	Remote exactly candidate; final own worktree clean

Successful precommit runs included the existing Denkraum suite (390 Node tests passed, 1 existing Windows-only skip; 33 Playwright tests passed). Full prepush also covered frontend coverage tests, HQ, lint, typecheck, Clippy and all remaining registered gates. A successful local commit alone was never treated as delivery.

NICHT ABGEDECKT

• Linux does not compile or run #[cfg(windows)] tests (run_in_pty, npm_shim, ConPTY, DPAPI) or Windows Clippy arms. The real Windows verdict runs in the merge queue; no ordinary PR stub is Windows evidence. Seven existing Rust skips and the existing Denkraum Windows 8.3 skip remain uncovered and unchanged.
• Precommit/prepush do not run the complete application Browser-Smoke, frontend build or all workflow gates of the linux lane. The executed Denkraum Playwright suite does not substitute for those. External updater, OmniRoute and mirror state is not checked.
• The start-check provider-limit and observation warnings are not quota/observation approval. Native model/header was observed separately. The lage-jetzt mirror and memory tool are unavailable in this worktree/session; live Git/PR evidence and the explicit bounded admission were used.
• All P00 future duties remain open: forbidden-zone refusal before effects per admitted harness/App/Shell/CLI/MCP and children; unborn first checkout; allowed parent, canonical roots, alias/case/UNC/link/TOCTOU and common Git administration identity; helper destinations and preservation of existing product AGENTS/CLAUDE; backup integrity and conflict-safe restore; independent product copy; passive viewer read permission.
• Pure string validation establishes no filesystem containment or authority. No PF/security/forbidden-zone/product/native/effective/user/parent acceptance, live creation, relocation, activation, grant, key or right is claimed. Later P02/P03/P06/P08/P16 dependencies remain binding.
• Independent source reviews, Root acceptance, current four canonical CI successes before queue, Windows queue evidence and merge are still pending.

Review disposition and next owner

Review: ausstehend (Stufe A).

No independent review findings have been commissioned or accepted by this worker. Root alone commissions and accepts the two distinct non-author families (Kimi/Moonshot and Anthropic), within the existing maximum two source rounds. Root owns Ready, review-ok and Mergify queue; Stabs owns PLAN. This handover delivers an inactive schema candidate, not protection or activation acceptance.

Delivery receipt

gh pr create --draft --base main --head codex/ms0-v36-p01 --body-file <report> exited 0.
Draft PR: #2043.
gh pr view 2043 --json url,isDraft,headRefOid,headRefName,baseRefName,body exited 0; draft, exact candidate SHA, base/head names and posted report were independently checked.

Root decision 2026-10-30 00:59Z (fix round 1): F3 resolved by dropping the unused FileZone enum (clippy -D warnings exit 101 after removing the asserts); F1 kept (private fields + getters). Review-forced round may use up to 400 RAW (AGENTS rule 1), forcing IDs R2043-F1/F3.