@@ -2,15 +2,16 @@
 # add-issue-or-pr.sh — reconcile a single issue or PR with the org
 # Initiatives project. An item belongs on the board iff it passes the
 # noise gate:
-#   - carries the required label (REQUIRED_LABEL, default `dev-lead`)
+#   - carries the required label (REQUIRED_LABEL) — but an EMPTY
+#     REQUIRED_LABEL means "no required label", which is how issues are
+#     un-gated (every issue tracked) while PRs keep the `dev-lead` gate;
 #   - carries NONE of the excluded labels (EXCLUDED_LABELS, default
-#     compliance-audit,health-check,fleet-tracker,daily-report) — the gate
-#     that keeps strategic work distinct from automation-generated work.
+#     compliance-audit,health-check,fleet-tracker,daily-report) — the noise
+#     filter that keeps automation-generated churn off the board.
 #
 # Reconcile, not just add (petry-projects/.github#415 §2): if an item that
-# was on the board stops qualifying — `dev-lead` removed, or an excluded
-# label added — its project item is removed. This is the issue/PR analogue
-# of reconcile-discussion.sh's state machine, built on the shared
+# was on the board stops qualifying — required label removed, or an excluded
+# label added — its project item is removed, built on the shared
 # find_project_item / delete_project_item helpers in lib.sh.
 #
 # Required env:
@@ -54,7 +55,11 @@ evaluate_noise_gate() {
     labels_json='[]'
   fi
 
-  local required="${REQUIRED_LABEL:-dev-lead}"
+  # ${VAR-default} (no colon): an unset REQUIRED_LABEL falls back to dev-lead,
+  # but an explicitly EMPTY value means "no required label" — every item
+  # qualifies (subject only to the excluded-labels filter). This is how issues
+  # are un-gated while PRs keep the dev-lead requirement.
+  local required="${REQUIRED_LABEL-dev-lead}"
   # Use ${VAR-default} (no colon): an unset EXCLUDED_LABELS falls back to the
   # default set, but an explicitly empty value means "no exclusions" so a repo
   # can opt out entirely.
@@ -74,7 +79,7 @@ evaluate_noise_gate() {
     --argjson excluded "${excluded_json}" \
     '
       [.[].name] as $names
-      | if ($names | index($required) | not) then
+      | if ($required != "" and ($names | index($required) | not)) then
           "missing:" + $required
         else
           ([$excluded[] | select(. as $e | $names | index($e))]) as $hits
 
@@ -15,24 +15,26 @@
 #      product-feature keywords.
 # Unmatched items are left BLANK and reported for triage — never guessed.
 Auto-rebase	auto.?rebase|update.?branch|rebase (bot|loop|collision)|conflict.?comment|dismiss.?stale|last.?push.?approval|stale.?base
-pr-review agent	pr.?review|(code|bot|single|advisory) review|review.?(one.?pr|decision|enumeration|loop|comments?|bot|gate|findings|annotation|enhancement|dismissal|tier|cycles?|retry)|single.?review|max_review|rubber duck|cascade|advisory.?bot|coderabbit|(gemini|copilot|sonarcloud|codex) review|fix.?request|extract_verdict|verdict|mention.?(ack|trigger)|changes_requested|@petry-review|@donpetry-bot|review-one-pr|list-prs|copilot suggest|github models|churn breaker|self.?trigger|downstream.?impact|pr_diff|mcp.*(review|tiers?|knob|config|server)|lsp (index|pilot|tool)|reviewer|awaiting review|#860
-Business Analyst	feature.?ideation|idea.?enhanc|idea.?triage|idea-enhancer|business analyst|enhance .*ideas?|single-idea enhancement|idea..?initiative pipeline
+pr-review agent	pr.?review|(code|bot|single|advisory) review|review.?(one.?pr|decision|enumeration|loop|comments?|bot|gate|findings|annotation|enhancement|dismissal|tier|cycles?|retry)|single.?review|max_review|rubber duck|cascade|advisory.?bot|coderabbit|(gemini|copilot|sonarcloud|codex) review|fix.?request|extract_verdict|verdict|mention.?(ack|trigger)|changes_requested|@petry-review|@donpetry-bot|review-one-pr|list-prs|copilot suggest|github models|churn breaker|self.?trigger|downstream.?impact|pr_diff|mcp.*(review|tiers?|knob|config|server)|lsp (index|pilot|tool)|reviewer|awaiting review|#860|rate-limit detector|triage tier|triage inline|review.?engine|copilot engine|engine (toggle|support)|fallback to copilot|small-pr|prioriti.e .*pr|automated feedback|lsp[_ ]pilot|poll-loop|addpullrequestreview|pr approvals
+Business Analyst	feature.?ideation|idea.?enhanc|idea.?triage|idea-enhancer|business analyst|enhance .*ideas?|single-idea enhancement|idea..?initiative pipeline|market research|epic checklist|open-questions|ready-for-dev|consumer manifest|plan\.json|grounding check|untracked .*prerequisite|strict-improvement|target_surface
 Model Selection	model.?(selection|fallback|tier|switch)|fallback model|opus.?fallback|retire .*(opus|gpt|claude-|model)|update to opus|opus 4|cross.?provider|provider.?switch|additional providers|providers,? .*model|engine.?(availability|model|upgrade)|multi-model chain|rate.?limit resilience
 Agent Shield	agent.?shield|prompt.?injection|input sanitiz|sanitiz|agent.?(security|hardening|governance)|jailbreak|secret.?redact|mcp.*(governance|allowlist|registry)|credential isolation|owasp|posture scoring|egress (firewall|policy|filter|rule)|firewall policy|trust escalation|agent autonomy
 Self-healing	self.?heal|auto.?remediat|auto.?fix|self.?repair|stall detect|pipeline stall|recovery escalation|kill switch|circuit breaker|runaway (protection|agent|pr)
-dev-lead agent	dev.?lead|deep.?impl|bmad|engine.?(timeout|error)|story churn|phantom.?spec|thin.?caller|inlined (claude|workflow)|claude\.yml|claude-fix|claude-?issue|claude code workflow|claude workflow|issue automation|prompting framework|devops agent persona|duplicate .*(pr|agent)|dedup|umbrella issue|in-progress label
-GH-AW	gh-?aw|agentic.?workflow|(^|[^[:alnum:]])aw([^[:alnum:]]|$)|ci.?failure|failure.?analyst|ci-?analyst|failure-to-agent|lock\.?file|lock\.yml|eval scorer|held-out|rubric|proposer|skill.?eval|skillopt|skill.?candidate|plan_json|artifact (type|contract)|self-improving|eval-case|evals/|agents\.md (spec|align)
+dev-lead agent	dev.?lead|deep.?impl|engine.?(timeout|error)|story churn|phantom.?spec|thin.?caller|inlined (claude|workflow)|claude\.yml|claude-fix|claude-?issue|claude code workflow|claude workflow|issue automation|prompting framework|devops agent persona|duplicate .*(pr|agent)|dedup|umbrella issue|in-progress label|claude-ci-fix|@claude|claude code|terminal coding agent|pi as org|pi harness|check_run|auto-merge
+GH-AW	gh-?aw|agentic.?workflow|(^|[^[:alnum:]])aw([^[:alnum:]]|$)|ci.?failure|failure.?analyst|ci-?analyst|failure-to-agent|lock\.?file|lock\.yml|eval scorer|held-out|rubric|proposer|skill.?eval|skillopt|skill.?candidate|plan_json|artifact (type|contract)|self-improving|eval-case|evals/|agents\.md (spec|align)|frameworks directory|frameworks/
 Copilot Instructions	copilot.*instruction|copilot coding agent|copilot governance|copilot custom|\.github/copilot|copilot-instructions
 Cost Observability	cost (attribution|observ|meter|arbitrage|report|api)|token.?(cost|savings|report|metric|observ)|budget (enforcement|circuit breaker|guardrail|tracking|aware)|credit budget|observability dashboard|opentelemetry|otel|effective token|\bet\b .*anomaly|usage & cost|billing-aware|batch api cost
 Fleet Monitor	fleet.?(monitor|tracker|view|health)|health.?check|hourly runs?|cron entr|scheduled .*(runs?|actions)
 Daily Reports	daily.?report|nightly.?report|status.?digest|org.?status
 Compliance Blitz	compliance.?blitz|compliance.?day|compliance backlog
-Org Standards	sonarcloud|sonar[ ._-]|s7[0-9]{3}|s86[0-9]{2}|s59[0-9]{2}|s3776|s5906|scorecard|ruleset|codeowners|branch.?(protection|ruleset)|push.?protection|ci.?standard|baseline|standards.?(sync|deploy|reconcile)|nosonar|secret.?scan|gitleaks|dependency.?(harden|pinning)|pin.*(sha|ref|reusable|version|action)|actionlint|yamllint|lint check|dependabot|org.?standard|org-wide .*(standard|instruction|reusable)|code.?quality|zizmor|oidc|access control|standards drift|drift.?(guard|detection)|integrity verification|execution protection|security linting|pull.?request.?limits|pr.?limits|admission gate|agents\.md|claude\.md|codeql|reusable workflow|apply-repo-settings|repo settings|profile readme|coding standard|ci pipeline|markdown lint|concurrency group|check-suite|slsa|attestation|bootstrap.?new.?repo|repo.?template|non-file policy|require .*discussions|has_discussions|structured logging|cqrs|stacked pr|worktree|convention|merge queue|noise reduction|cognitive complexity|jest assertion
+Org Standards	sonarcloud|sonar[ ._-]|s7[0-9]{3}|s86[0-9]{2}|s59[0-9]{2}|s3776|s5906|scorecard|ruleset|codeowners|branch.?(protection|ruleset)|push.?protection|ci.?standard|baseline|standards.?(sync|deploy|reconcile)|nosonar|secret.?scan|gitleaks|dependency.?(harden|pinning)|pin.*(sha|ref|reusable|version|action)|actionlint|yamllint|lint check|dependabot|org.?standard|org-wide .*(standard|instruction|reusable)|code.?quality|zizmor|oidc|access control|standards drift|drift.?(guard|detection)|integrity verification|execution protection|security linting|pull.?request.?limits|pr.?limits|admission gate|agents\.md|claude\.md|codeql|reusable workflow|apply-repo-settings|repo settings|profile readme|coding standard|ci pipeline|markdown lint|concurrency group|check-suite|slsa|attestation|bootstrap.?new.?repo|repo.?template|non-file policy|require .*discussions|has_discussions|structured logging|cqrs|stacked pr|worktree|convention|merge queue|noise reduction|cognitive complexity|jest assertion|ci\.yml|gh_pat|pat auth|machine user|repository settings|ci/cd standard|new-repo|pr.?limit|fail loud|never fake|orchestration guidance
 Compliance program	compliance|audit|remediat
 Release Strategy	release.?(strategy|train|notes|channel|cadence|automation|cut|soak|ring)|cut.?release|autocut|soak.?(promote|and-promote)|ring.?(rollout|promote|enrol|stag)|channel.?(promote|cut|soak|pin)|canary|version(ing)? (scheme|standard)|semantic versioning|tag protection|rollback|promote .*(channel|ring|stable)
-Initiatives Project	initiative|add.?to.?project|projects? v2|project board|roadmap view|initiatives project|issue.?fields|github projects
+Initiatives Project	initiative|add.?to.?project|projects? v2|project board|roadmap view|initiatives project|issue.?fields|github projects|updateprojectv2field|option.?wipe
 Tooling	tooling|scratchpad|dev.?tool|utility script|template gallery
 Broodly	/broodly|broodminder|\bhive\b|honey|nectar|bloom|colony|\bmite|apiary|beekeep|hornet|treatment efficacy|nfc and qr|acoustic colony|zero-tap|off-season engagement
 Markets	/markets|snap/ebt|produce recognition|app-averse|failed-trip|vendor catalog|north-star|discover filter|sms check-in
 Google App Scripts	/google-app-scripts|apps? script|script_catalog|gmail|deployed-script
-TalkTerm	/talkterm|avatar|elevenlabs|lip-sync|screen companion|companion mode|3d avatar|spatial audio|byok|effort modes|voice (assistant|agent|interface|provider|transcription)|conversational (voice|oauth|permission|mcp|onboarding)|screenshot context|deliberation mode|emotion-aware|multi-language voice|infinite conversation|on-device (voice|ai)|vision-native
+TalkTerm	/talkterm|avatar|elevenlabs|lip-sync|screen companion|companion mode|3d avatar|spatial audio|byok|effort modes|voice (assistant|agent|interface|provider|transcription)|conversational (voice|oauth|permission|mcp|onboarding)|screenshot context|deliberation mode|emotion-aware|multi-language voice|infinite conversation|on-device (voice|ai)|vision-native|natural language automation|shareable session|workspace intelligence|contextual workspace|conversational recurring|visual workflow replay
+ContentTwin	/contenttwin|content.?twin
+BMAD	/bmad-bgreat|bmad-bgreat|bmad suite|bmad method|bmad-method|\bbmad\b|bmad
@@ -19,7 +19,9 @@ Tooling	Tooling
 Ad hoc	Ad hoc
 Business Analyst	Agentic Framework
 Cost Observability	Fleet Operations
-TalkTerm	Products
-Broodly	Products
-Markets	Products
-Google App Scripts	Products
+TalkTerm	TalkTerm
+Broodly	Broodly
+Markets	Markets
+Google App Scripts	Google App Scripts
+ContentTwin	ContentTwin
+BMAD	Agentic Framework
@@ -7,18 +7,19 @@
 #      GitHub does not fire workflows from default-token events, so
 #      `issues: opened` never triggers the add; and
 #   2. runs dropped under runner congestion (no retry).
-# This scans each repo's OPEN issues/PRs + Ideas discussions and reconciles each
-# with the board using the SAME gate + helpers as the event path
-# (evaluate_noise_gate / reconcile_content_with_project / reconcile_discussion),
-# so a missed item lands within one reconcile cycle regardless of author/token.
+# This scans each repo's OPEN issues/PRs and reconciles each with the board
+# using the SAME gate + helpers as the event path (evaluate_noise_gate /
+# reconcile_content_with_project), so a missed item lands within one reconcile
+# cycle regardless of author/token. Issues are un-gated (every issue tracked);
+# PRs keep the required-label gate. Discussions are not tracked.
 # Idempotent; honours DRY_RUN=1 (logs intended actions, mutates nothing).
 #
 # Env:
 #   PROJECT_ID       ProjectV2 node ID of the Initiatives project   (required)
 #   PROJECT_URL      human-readable URL (logging only)
-#   REQUIRED_LABEL   gate's required label   (default: dev-lead)
+#   REQUIRED_LABEL   PR gate's required label (default: dev-lead); issues are
+#                    un-gated regardless
 #   EXCLUDED_LABELS  gate's excluded labels  (default in add-issue-or-pr.sh)
-#   IDEAS_CATEGORY   discussion category tracked as drafts (default: Ideas)
 #   RECON_REPOS      space-separated owner/repo list to scan
 #                    (default: the planner App installation's repositories)
 #   DRY_RUN          "1" → log only
@@ -28,15 +29,12 @@ set -euo pipefail
 _dir="$(cd -- "$(dirname -- "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")" && pwd)"
 # shellcheck source=.github/scripts/add-to-project/add-issue-or-pr.sh
 source "${_dir}/add-issue-or-pr.sh"       # reconcile_content_with_project (+ lib.sh)
-# shellcheck source=.github/scripts/add-to-project/reconcile-discussion.sh
-source "${_dir}/reconcile-discussion.sh"  # reconcile_discussion
 
 : "${PROJECT_ID:?PROJECT_ID is required}"
-ideas_category="${IDEAS_CATEGORY:-Ideas}"
-# Exported (with default applied) so the discussions --jq filter can read it via
-# `env.RECON_IDEAS_CATEGORY` instead of shell-interpolating it — avoids jq syntax
-# breakage / injection if the category name contains quotes or backslashes.
-export RECON_IDEAS_CATEGORY="${ideas_category}"
+# Issues are un-gated; PRs keep the required-label gate. Capture the PR gate
+# from the incoming REQUIRED_LABEL (default dev-lead) before the loop overrides
+# it per item.
+pr_required="${REQUIRED_LABEL-dev-lead}"
 
 # Resolve target repos: explicit RECON_REPOS, else the App installation's repos.
 declare -a repos
@@ -56,45 +54,28 @@ for repo in "${repos[@]}"; do
   [ -z "$repo" ] && continue
   echo "::group::${repo}"
 
-  # Open issues AND PRs (the issues endpoint returns both; the gate applies to
-  # both identically). Pass labels as the objects array the gate expects.
-  # Fetch into a variable so an API failure is surfaced (not silenced) and
-  # `set -e`'s check isn't bypassed by a subshell; feed the loop via here-string
-  # so it stays in the parent shell and `scanned` is updated correctly.
+  # Open issues AND PRs (the issues endpoint returns both). A PR carries a
+  # `.pull_request` object; emit that so the loop can apply the required-label
+  # gate to PRs only — issues are un-gated. Pass labels as the objects array
+  # the gate expects. Fetch into a variable so an API failure is surfaced (not
+  # silenced) and `set -e`'s check isn't bypassed by a subshell; feed the loop
+  # via here-string so it stays in the parent shell and `scanned` updates.
   issues_tsv=$(gh api --paginate "repos/${repo}/issues?state=open&per_page=100" \
-            --jq '.[] | [.node_id, .html_url, ([.labels[] | {name}] | @json)] | @tsv') || {
+            --jq '.[] | [.node_id, .html_url, ([.labels?[]? | {name}] | @json), (if .pull_request then "pr" else "issue" end)] | @tsv') || {
     echo "::error::failed to fetch issues for ${repo}" >&2
     echo "::endgroup::"
     continue
   }
-  while IFS=$'\t' read -r nid url labels; do
+  while IFS=$'\t' read -r nid url labels kind || [ -n "$kind" ]; do
+    kind="${kind%$'\r'}"
     [ -z "$nid" ] && continue
     scanned=$((scanned + 1))
-    reconcile_content_with_project "$nid" "$url" "$labels" || true
+    # Un-gate issues (empty required label); PRs keep the gate.
+    if [ "$kind" = "pr" ]; then REQUIRED_LABEL="$pr_required"; else REQUIRED_LABEL=""; fi
+    export REQUIRED_LABEL
+    reconcile_content_with_project "$nid" "$url" "$labels"
   done <<< "$issues_tsv"
 
-  # Open Ideas-category discussions → draft items. Same robustness as above; the
-  # category is read inside jq via `env.RECON_IDEAS_CATEGORY` (set earlier) rather
-  # than shell-interpolated, so special characters can't break or inject into it.
-  discussions_tsv=$(gh api graphql --paginate -f owner="${repo%%/*}" -f name="${repo##*/}" -f query='
-    query($owner:String!,$name:String!,$endCursor:String){
-      repository(owner:$owner,name:$name){
-        discussions(first:100,after:$endCursor,states:OPEN){
-          pageInfo{hasNextPage endCursor}
-          nodes{number title url category{name}}
-        }
-      }
-    }' --jq '.data.repository.discussions.nodes[] | select(.category.name==env.RECON_IDEAS_CATEGORY) | [(.number|tostring), .title, .url] | @tsv') || {
-    echo "::error::failed to fetch discussions for ${repo}" >&2
-    echo "::endgroup::"
-    continue
-  }
-  while IFS=$'\t' read -r number title url; do
-    [ -z "$number" ] && continue
-    scanned=$((scanned + 1))
-    reconcile_discussion "$number" "$title" "$url" "$ideas_category" || true
-  done <<< "$discussions_tsv"
-
   echo "::endgroup::"
 done